From my experience, almost every company I have dealt with will issue a refund if your return a product in original condition, if the purchaser is not satisfied with it. Most vendors here in Ca have a 30 day return policy. As far as I am concerned, any retail store that has a no refund policy is a store I will not deal with, as they are the exception, not the norm.
As a matter of fact, here is the Ca take on this: In California, retailers that won’t give a full refund or credit, allow an equal exchange, or any combination of these options, within seven days of purchase when goods are returned with a receipt, must clearly display their policy at each cash register and sales counter, at each public entrance, on tags attached to each item sold under the policy, or on the retail seller’s order forms, if any.
This requirement does not apply to perishable items (like food or plants), items that are marked as final sale, goods used or damaged after purchase, custom orders, goods not returned with their original packaging, and items that can’t be resold for health reasons.
If a store violates this law (California Civil Code section 1723) by not conspicuously displaying their limited or no return policy, the customer can return the purchased item with proof of purchase for a full refund within 30 days. You can notify the consumer protection division of your local district attorney’s office of any violations, or file a complaint online with the Attorney General’s office by visiting
Consumer Complaint Against A Business/Company | State of California - Department of Justice - Office of the Attorney General.
So, depending on the state this took place in, Muley Freak may very well be violating the law.
When so many reputable companies offer a no fault/satisfaction guarantee, there is no point in doing business with companies like Muley Freak, they just don't measure up, clearly not meeting the level of customer support most people have come to expect.
Based on what IdahoSandman stated, if true, and that the OP is based in Ca (Ca law applies, despite sell location) MF clearly violated Ca law/consumer protections.