Black tail deer caliber for 2024

[mtnbound]

223 and 75gr ELDM’s if legal. 6CM with either 108 or 103 ELD’s.

 

[Pharmseller]

What?? Where is the 7mm08!!

I wanted to try something new.

The Mighty -08 is on the docket for elk.




P

 

[idig4au]

6.5x257 wby with 127 gr LRX

 

[limpet]

Well 243 worked well on a quartering to shot at 250 yards. My girlfriend got her first buck using 88 grain hammer hunter and I have more faith in these bullets now

 

[Jdavis77]

Ace rifles is building me a new 22 creed. So this year I’ll be using my 338 federal. I love the short action 1-300 yard guns

 

[roosiebull]

Yes I'm a baby! Only been hunting for a few years so I ain't got the breadth of experience many roksliders have.

The mighty-08 hasn't let me down yet in the seasons I've been able to connect with deers so far!

First few years I was shooting nosler partition bullets, haven't been able to find those easily since the pandemic other than the stash my old man left behind so I've switched to hornady vmax and SSTs for the time being. Got some hornady cx as well but I dunno if I'm gonna get serious about mono bullets unless I actually go to Cali or other places that ban lead projectiles.

Actually gonna be using slugs this season as I got an opportunity to hunt on one of the islands in WA where it's got firearm restrictions limiting to archery, muzzie or shotguns.

If you were stuck slug hunting would you go 12 or 20 gauge?

I would get a 20ga without question, I know that they kill elk well, and the reduction in recoil alone is worth it

I hate shooting slugs in general, but 20ga are not as punishing

Between the cost of good slugs and recoil, slug gun shooting doesn’t feel very recreational

 

[limpet]

Actually gonna be using slugs this season as I got an opportunity to hunt on one of the islands in WA where it's got firearm restrictions limiting to archery, muzzie or shotguns.

If you were stuck slug hunting would you go 12 or 20 gauge?

I can attest to 20 gauge slugs being deadly on blacktails. My only solo double was with a 20 gauge pump. They were Barnes mono and were pretty effective. A lead slug would be even better.

 

[Taudisio]

20 gauge blacktails. First one was on the run and a finisher to his neck. About 75 yards. Second one at about 85. Shooting federal 3” truball slugs from a mossberg 500 and modified choke. I’m pretty sure I took these photos with a razor flip phone for a timeline of when they were taken.

 

[screedler]

For the 20ga wizards, what choke do you end up running?

Tried out my browning bps 20ga with some federal slugs this weekend and I think i was using the wrong choke for the best accuracy! Gotta bring all my choke tubes next time and do some better testing choke for choke to dial in what this specific shotty likes the most.

Got permission to hunt the island confirmed so my slug testing is on for real now!!

 

[Taudisio]

For the 20ga wizards, what choke do you end up running?

Tried out my browning bps 20ga with some federal slugs this weekend and I think i was using the wrong choke for the best accuracy! Gotta bring all my choke tubes next time and do some better testing choke for choke to dial in what this specific shotty likes the most.

Got permission to hunt the island confirmed so my slug testing is on for real now!!

The stock modified from mossberg. Shot 3” groups with the double bead at 100 yards. I killed deer with that setup from 75-156 yards.

 

[screedler]

The stock modified from mossberg modified. Shot 3” groups with the double bead at 100 yards. I killed deer with that setup from 75-156 yards.

I think my problem was I had my improved cylinder choke in my 20ga. D'oh!

Switched to modified, now to go back to the woods and re-test! Thank you for your suggestion. That's some impressive performance you've gotten

 

[FairWeatherFisher]

30-30 when it’s not raining, 308 when it is. That’s purely based on the furniture each sports. I don’t want that nice old walnut getting soaked.

 

[shootnrun]

No love for the 25-06. But there will be at least one chasing blacktails come the end of the month

 

[roosiebull]

No love for the 25-06. But there will be at least one chasing blacktails come the end of the month

Until recently, I really wanted a 257wby as my “1 rifle” and then became a little more practical and decided the 25-06 was the one. I think quarter bores are awesome, always have

Now I will likely never own one, but I still like them and hope they don’t go the way of the dinosaur

If they keep expanding heavier 25 call options, I may have something built, I have always thought there was something cool about 25 cals

 

[Or.hunter]

6.5 PRC shooting 156gr Berger eol. We call it the Blacktail Hammer.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Coreyamyas]

View attachment 763848

those are incredible. Going to do a mount of some kind?

 

[Coreyamyas]

30.06 with 180 partitions. Same thing I shoot at every other animal.

 

[landis07]

Usually shot a Tikka .270wsm but did a build off a Tikka .300wsm this year so I shot this buck at 246 in the neck with nosler 180 accubonds

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[BKM]

6.5cm. With a 147eldm for me and my kids this year. I really wanted the 130 tmk to work out but the 147eldm is just so darn accurate I couldn’t do it.

It’s my first year with a 6.5cm, but n the past my 308 with a 165sst was a hammer on deer

 

[Northwest_stillwater]

7PRC 175gr eldx factory ammo.i picked one gun to hunt both roosevelts and blacktails with when i made my purchase last year. almost half inch groups at 100yds and a clean ethical kill on my first buck thus far