Best Advice for First Time OTC Colorado

Marble

WKR
Joined
May 29, 2019
Messages
3,557
That is slightly discouraging but thanks for the reply. I would prefer not to see anyone even if that means less chance of taking a big bull, but seems like no matter where in Colorado you will run into people.

Have you hunted 3rd rifle season? This might be another option for me.
Don't let your expectations be squashed. Do the trip you want, use a trail and then leave it.

Don't let people discourage you.

If it were me going to a new area, I would want to scout it. This is mainly for figuring out a lot of the logistics of the area.

Usually I do not just hit a trailhead blindly. I'll usually venture out until I find sign and then plan from there.

Be mobile, take breaks, and don't be obsessed with success.

Sent from my SM-G986U using Tapatalk
 

trevvamos

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Aug 7, 2016
Messages
142
Location
Bend OR
In between jobs I have about 2 weeks this September and looking to do an OTC Archery trip in Colorado. This will be my first elk trip and first time hunting Colorado. If time permits I plan to scout before the season, but that is unknown at this time.

Besides finding water source big or small what other suggestions do you have for first timer?

I plan to do a solo trip with a 5-7 day pack.
Just go…. you could scour forums, podcasts etc and get a million different opinions, but nothing beats boots on the ground. Keep at it, and pretty soon it will start to click.
 

pcrossett

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
May 9, 2022
Messages
112
Location
Colorado
Train, train and train some more, the more physically prepared you are going in to it the better. Won't tie directly to you finding elk but will make going over that one next ridge easier where they may be.
 

skissell

FNG
Joined
Mar 6, 2023
Messages
11
Make sure you are physically in shape to do a solo backcountry hunt. The mountains are a lot steeper than what they appear on a topo map. I would really hike as much as possible before your trip with the exact weight or heavier than what you plan on carrying during the hunt. Be confident in your ability to stay out there solo, have a good medkit and get familiar with the items and learn how to use them.

Once you're there it's all about how much determination you have to find the elk, they are there but sometimes you have to put the miles on to find them, but not always. Tons of information on YouTube as well, that was a good source for me when I started. Goodluck!
 

Jaquomo

WKR
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
415
Hey, how did I go from WKR to "lil Rokslider, LOL?

You'll see way fewer hunters and likely more elk if you put in those boot leather miles within a mile or two from the road, then move your camp and keep moving until you find elk. Usually, water is not an issue for elk. Hunters are the issue, and the influencers have made everybody into a "waybacker" wannabe. The further in you go, the more friends you'll make.

Go with an open mind, be mobile, and don't get discouraged. I hunt a 400 square mile area and sometimes move my camp every 3-4 days until I find elk. Last year I bowhunted a new area for two weeks, had 11 camps near me, was into elk almost every day within a mile of roads, and only ever saw three other hunters in the woods.
 

CMF

WKR
Joined
May 8, 2019
Messages
869
Location
Mississippi
That is slightly discouraging but thanks for the reply. I would prefer not to see anyone even if that means less chance of taking a big bull, but seems like no matter where in Colorado you will run into people.

Have you hunted 3rd rifle season? This might be another option for me.
There's a good chance the people are where the elk are. Are you looking for a camping trip or an elk hunt? As others have said, they could be a half mile from the road or 10 miles, but it's a lot easier to find them without 30 or 40lbs of gear on your back. If you know you have time off, why be set on OTC when it's still application season?
 

def90

WKR
Joined
Aug 12, 2020
Messages
1,696
Location
Colorado
Keep in mind that wherever you hike in to if you beat the odds and are successful you will need to make a minimum of 4 round trips to haul everything out. It sounds great to hike in 5 miles and gain 3-4k feet in elevation until you realize you need to get everything out by yourself before the meat goes bad.

Other than that it's OTC so keep your expectations in check and have fun with it.
 

Eastcoasthunter94

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 15, 2020
Messages
128
Location
Upstate New York
There's a good chance the people are where the elk are. Are you looking for a camping trip or an elk hunt? As others have said, they could be a half mile from the road or 10 miles, but it's a lot easier to find them without 30 or 40lbs of gear on your back. If you know you have time off, why be set on OTC when it's still application season?
^^^^ take this advice and do some research on drawing a tag. There are quite a few state drawings still open and you can find a much higher quality hunt than OTC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CMF
OP
B

bkusna15

FNG
Joined
Nov 2, 2022
Messages
17
I did put in for the draw but my expectations are low since this is my first year applying. Looks like i might have to change my game plan, lighten the load to the neccessites, and search for elk before i even think about setting up a camp.

This will be my first experience getting an elk is the goal, but learning the land and understanding there movements is part of the experience for me as well.
 
Joined
Feb 27, 2012
Messages
2,721
Location
Tijeras NM
I did put in for the draw but my expectations are low since this is my first year applying. Looks like i might have to change my game plan, lighten the load to the neccessites, and search for elk before i even think about setting up a camp.

This will be my first experience getting an elk is the goal, but learning the land and understanding there movements is part of the experience for me as well.
Yeah understanding their movements when pressured vs not pressured is a night and day difference. But once pressured elk feel safe, they go back to feeling un pressured again.
 

raptor16

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 28, 2019
Messages
265
Location
NW Arkansas
Basically what everyone else has said, research old threads on this and then just go and do it.

I did my first elk hunt in 2020, solo OTC archery in CO. Drove all over the state (for fun as much as anything). Saw a couple of elk in two very different units. The first one I saw I wasn't expecting it all. I was maybe a 3/4 mile in right on a hiking trail with a herd of beef cows around. Turned around to check out my surroundings and saw a cow elk within range that had no idea I was there, too many trees for a shot. I never expected to see her right then right there.

I think a lot of it is luck. My friend killed a nice bull this fall 5 minutes after shooting light on opening morning. We can't claim anything but dumb luck on our part aside from getting out early and having other hunters push him toward us haha! We might've been 1,000 yards from the road.
 

Attachments

  • C190BB0F-9927-40B6-A578-0A92F4AC2A15.jpeg
    C190BB0F-9927-40B6-A578-0A92F4AC2A15.jpeg
    689.5 KB · Views: 67
Joined
Oct 3, 2017
Messages
1,099
Location
Too far east
My friend killed a nice bull this fall 5 minutes after shooting light on opening morning. We can't claim anything but dumb luck on our part aside from getting out early and having other hunters push him toward us haha! We might've been 1,000 yards from the road.
That's how I deer hunt on state land. There is a high road, and a low road. I go in early, and sit in-between the 2 roads. Deer are pushed to me at sunrise.
 

jgilber5

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Dec 31, 2021
Messages
181
Location
New Mexico
People make it seem like the elk will run miles away when pressure hits, and go way high or down low. Don't overlook the nasty stuff just lateral to the prime spots. Don't be discouraged by vehicles at your access point. Last year was my first year, tons of rigs where I parked, but everybody was 4 miles over the ridge into the far basin, while the elk and I were less that a mile away.
 
Joined
Dec 15, 2022
Messages
13
Location
Kentucky
In between jobs I have about 2 weeks this September and looking to do an OTC Archery trip in Colorado. This will be my first elk trip and first time hunting Colorado. If time permits I plan to scout before the season, but that is unknown at this time.

Besides finding water source big or small what other suggestions do you have for first timer?

I plan to do a solo trip with a 5-7 day pack.
Done our first DIY OTC Colorado Elk hunt last year. Last two weeks of September. Didn't have any luck. But we had fun and learned a lot of what not to do. Seen some other hunters but not what we expected to see. But that was probably because there were no Elk where we were.😜
 
Joined
Dec 15, 2022
Messages
13
Location
Kentucky
Just go…. you could scour forums, podcasts etc and get a million different opinions, but nothing beats boots on the ground. Keep at it, and pretty soon it will start to click.
Agree with this.....all the e-scouting will still not prepare you for actually dealing with it in person. The perspective is totally different. Oh, and depending on where you are coming from be prepared to deal with altitude sickness. It doesn't happen to everybody but it does happen.
 

Huntin_GI

WKR
Joined
Apr 14, 2016
Messages
379
Location
N. Colorado
Go elsewhere. Idaho draw is still open. Hell, even Colorados draw is still open. OTC is an absolute shit show. Emphasis on shit.
 

venado mula

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jul 8, 2022
Messages
207
Come to MT and harvest elk, we have too many of them and get as many whitetail tags as possible. Seriously, we need to have more elk harvested, all of them.
 
Top