Same outfitter. They've been super helpful, probably answered 50 questions over text and email the last few months. Will see how the hunt goes, will let you know so you know what to expect
No shots fired from me. We had three hunters, one guy got a small four-pointer.
For this hunt, it has a lot to do with the tradeoffs between amoutn of daylight elevation. In early December, you have about seven hours of daylight, which is not much time to get up sheer 40 degree inclines to 2000ft, which is the lowest you'll start to see those deer. And they may not even be on that mountain face, and you won't have time to try a second location.
But the upside is that if there's 6" or more of snow, the blacktails will have descended down the mountain and won't take as long to get to. You may even see them on the shoreline eating seaweed.
I did not see one deer, fox or anything other than ducks after 5 days of hunting. Lot's of overnight sign, but no eyes on. It was simply a cold but low-snow winter, which is the gamble you take when you book 6 months in advance. They managed to stay on the top of the mountains and on faces I simply couldn't get to and get back down by dark. They simply know where they're safe from shore-dropped hunters at dawn.
I recommend not hunting in an El Nina season, which 2025 was, unless you expect you'll be able to account for the drier conditions and anticipate nontypical deer habbits.
Also I recommend hunting earlier in the year, as these deer seem to be very pressured by all the lodges in the area, and with less daylight and steeper inclines you just don't want to be hiking that hard and only get a couple hours window to possibly sight a buck. Better to have to hike higher elevation, but have much more time to get there and stay there, with deer that aren't yet pressured by your presence.
Something I also learned after getting to Kodiac is that the south is gently rolling hills, and the north is where all those 40 degree inclines are. And there are just as many deer and lodges on the north as south. So do with that information what you will.
The hunt for me was a worse case scenario, which is to say an incredible, once in a lifetime hiking trip with some ducks to mount.