I have a Peak 44 Blacktooth and Bastion and a Manners Eh1. I have also have used the Stockys sporter.
For a lightweight general purpose hunting rifle, I think my preference is the Blacktooth. I really like the weight and ergos.
For more of a long range type rig, I like the Bastion well enough… I wish it had some texture on the grip though, and a slightly longer grip.
The EH1 I would also use on a long range type. I find it is a little fat in the hands. It’s also much heavier than the Peak 44’s. I replaced it with the Bastion.
The Stockys is just ok. I replaced it with the Blacktooth. I don’t like its straight comb and its inletting is not as clean; factory or aftermarket bottom metal doesn’t sit flush. Also the forend is more rounded, which I don’t like.
All but the EH1 I had bedded. The Peak 44 have aluminum pillars which is nice.
For my style of hunting and therefore my preference of style of rifle, I lean to the Blacktooth.