So, to conclude this, I bought three pads and three pillows and tested them all while sleeping on them at home. I also measured my sleep scores on each.
Pads:
- Sea to Summit either Light XT Pro
- Big Agnes Rapid SL Large
- Thermarest Neo Air Lite (not XT)
Pillows:
- Klymit Blown Up
- Outdoor Vitals Blown Up
- Custom Goose Feet Gear with clothes stuffed in
- Just a puffy in the sleeping pad bag
The Big Agnes’s Goose Feet Gear combo is what I used all season and had much better sleep. That combo also scored the highest sleep scores at home and performed much better in the field compared to last year.
My conclusion: Take the 1 lb penalty and get better sleep.