Nice rifle! Why do sitka deer always look like baby deer? Every harvest picture I've seen looks like a two year old deer at best to my untrained eyes. Do the grizzley bears keep them from growing old or something?
That’s just how they are. They have small, stocky bodies and compact antlers. Google “record Sitka blacktail” or similar and when looking at those pics keep in mind that those are the biggest examples of the species. Not very big…
Yes, bears eat a lot blacktails, but only newborn fawns, not mature deer.
Further, It’s not uncommon for old deer to regress to forked antler configuration and aging coastal deer by tooth wear is unreliable due to teeth being prematurely worn from eating sandy kelp on the beaches during big snow winters. All that to say, aging Sitka blacktail can be tricky.
For me, looking at the width of a bucks antlers compared to his ears is the easiest way to field judge. In my opinion, a “good” buck will be well outside the ears, the farther the better.
Here’s a few examples of young blacktail bucks from this year.
1 yo bucks will generally be a spike or a very weak fork and will keep their velvet longer than older bucks. Like this:
2 yo bucks will generally be forks or weak 3x3s, with very little mass. Like these:
Here’s an older deer from two seasons ago. He’s “good” by my standards, but not very impressive unless you’re a Sitka blacktail enthusiast. Well outside the ears, gray muzzle, blind in one eye.
