Gunnersdad49
WKR
I just returned from a 12 day fly in trip to Alaska. We had some pieces of gear that worked really well, and some that failed completely. I thought I would share my experiences as they may help others with their purchases.
First off: Water filters. My partner and I each brought a filter, along with having the ability to boil water, or use purification tablets.
He bought the most recommended filtration pump the local sporting goods store had. It was the Katadyn Hiker Pro. It filters water quickly, and he "made water" for the two of us for the first two days out of the lake. The lake was weirdly colored from the tannins in the tundra that feeds the lake. The water was clear, but colored, so no big muddy water particles, etc. We made about 8 liters of water per day for drinking, coffee, and dehydrated meals. His pump worked great on day 1. On day 2, it got harder and harder to pump. We disassembled it, couldn't see any issues other than a coloration on the filter. By day 3 it was really hard to pump, and it broke where the filter housing threads onto the pump head. Catastrophic failure.
I used my Sawyer Squeeze for the rest of the trip with no issues, back flushing it twice. (no option or method for backflushing the Katadyn.
First off: Water filters. My partner and I each brought a filter, along with having the ability to boil water, or use purification tablets.
He bought the most recommended filtration pump the local sporting goods store had. It was the Katadyn Hiker Pro. It filters water quickly, and he "made water" for the two of us for the first two days out of the lake. The lake was weirdly colored from the tannins in the tundra that feeds the lake. The water was clear, but colored, so no big muddy water particles, etc. We made about 8 liters of water per day for drinking, coffee, and dehydrated meals. His pump worked great on day 1. On day 2, it got harder and harder to pump. We disassembled it, couldn't see any issues other than a coloration on the filter. By day 3 it was really hard to pump, and it broke where the filter housing threads onto the pump head. Catastrophic failure.
I used my Sawyer Squeeze for the rest of the trip with no issues, back flushing it twice. (no option or method for backflushing the Katadyn.