Looking at this again, i'm not so sure i think its just short freebore.. Would have to be a VERY short freebore spec to scrape that close to the case mouth, basically zero. Is that scraping around the whole circumference of the bullet? The sharpie pics make it look like it's on one side which would indicate something like an off center chamber or other chamber defect. If it's the whole way around either the guy has an oddball reamer or it's cutting under spec freebore.
Weird thing is how wide that scraping is and there is no indication of different depths from land/groove transitions.