I think the extra mass of aluminum would help it in the wind, but carbon should handle small vibrations better. I look forward to hearing more.
Can you give feedback on the noise you experience? I felt my aluminum tripod (vortex) was louder and gave sharp sounds whereas my carbon (slik) is a...
As my boots break in to my foot, lacing seems to help secure me from sliding more than when they are new and stiff. If you’re smashing your toes in the toe box I would be concerned. If it’s just a little movement I would break them in more and lock the laces lower on the boot to be more secure.
I have favorite pieces from each company. My hunting buddies have different pieces that are their favorites from each company. Mix and match with the best deals you can find. you will eventually narrow down exactly what you like and all the offerings become less complicated.
If you’re only needing a 40-50 I would look at the soft coolers (hopper style). Way more versatile and seems to be 75% or so of the insulation of the hard yeti. I lost 2 deer in a Coleman on one trip. Never had a problem with my hoppers. For things like weekend trips, flying, kayaking, they are...