Thanks, nothing better than reviews from actual hands on.
Larry, Agreed on the torso length I need to measure her! I'm fairly sure she is done growing upward so the torso length should be stable for years to come and I think she should get something that will work for awhile. She doesn't hunt but does scout with me a lot and she has joined a backpacking club at school so the pack will have to be big enough to carry all she would need if I wasn't going with her although I will probably volunteer to go on the school trips, anyway to big is better than to small.
Beastmode, The Gregory Deva is a great looking pack! but unless I can get one on a scratch and dent sale she probably can't afford one of those. Does your daughter give it high reviews? Has she used it much?
Luke, The price of this pack is more in line with what she will be able to afford especially if I get it on a scratch and dent sale + the 20% end of the year coupon, Do you think the 52 is big enough? seems a little small.