Your handgun Hunting setup

Kodiak

FNG
Joined
Feb 8, 2016
Messages
60
Location
NW WYO
I am looking to start hunting antelope and maybe elk with a hand gun. I have a Ruger Super Redhawk in .454 and was thinking of putting a scope on it this spring.

What do you use? Gun and scope? Holsters for a gun with a scope? I would love to see what you are using and any thoughts good, bad, and ugly about your set up or handgun hunting in general.
 
I have a ruger super blackhawk hunter with the built in scope scallops. I havn't scoped it yet though.
 
Kodiak, I sold my hunting handgun set-up but I wish that I would have kept it or traded it for something else. I had a Ruger Super RedHawk 44 mag with the integrated scope mounts/rings. I hunted with it and loved it for hunting turkeys and deer here in the hills. Eventually it ended up being one of those guns that was fun to shoot but I needed to practice with a lot to really be comfortable with in the field. Another gun bug hit and it was sold off to pay for new project. I had a cheap 4x simmons scope on it and carried it in a uncle mikes bandoleer style holster. I liked the gun and with lots of practice and trigger time, I felt that I could shoot it well (5 shots in the inner part of 8" paper plate at 75 yds). I enjoyed hunting with it especially for turkeys, a super light load of Unique powder was the ticket.
If I had to do things over, I would go with a 2x scope but higher end optics. I liked the 44 mag but would probably go 460 or 454 for the added range and versatility of the lighter rounds for practice. Mine had 7.5 " barrel and although heavy, that is about right in my opinion. Moreover, I would upgrade guns or grips to find the one that REALLY fit me well. The big boomers are made worse when the grips don't fit your hands correctly! The bandoleer holster served me well but I know there are better options. The only other things to make sure of and practice with are ear plugs and a shooting rest. I used a bipod but with a pistol, I think a tripod would be better.
Even though I never elk hunted with a pistol, I think it would be a great time and completely possible especially with a little more range with the 454.
Best of Luck
IMG_2851.JPG
 
Awesome. Thanks Bearlodge. Why would you have preferred a 2 over a 4x scope? We’re you running into target acquisition issues?
 
Yes, with my maximum range being 75-80 yards, I found that the 4x scope gave me a little too much magnification. Really bothered me with the magnification of my movements in trying to keep the revolver steady. I think that having the right iron sights or the 2x scope would have helped with it. I think that a 4x on a contender style gun in 30-30 or 7-30 waters would be the ticket.
 
Speed goats and elk.... now you're talkin'... Range, range and more range. Hunt em' like a bow hunter with a wheelgun... sneek up and shoot from short range or figure out how to extend your range. I put handgunning in to two general categories. Pistol cartages... straight walled with a big bullet, or a bottleneck cartridge that has the range. For a wheelgun, its a short range proposition of 100 yds or thereabouts so a low magnification scope is in order... maybe even a red dot type sight... which is faster to acquire the sights with ... its like muzzy hunting but more difficult with faster followup shots. A 44 mag is my personal choice for that kind of hunting with open sights or a very low powered scope. A 4X scope is a little too much in my opinion for a revolver but some like it. Iv'e gone to pretty much open sights as the range your limited to is short and open sights are faster and the system is lighter and easy to handle.

For ranges beyond 100 yds, I go with a single shot platform... in my case a TC Encore. I go with a scope of 4x... or higher magnification but really like a 4x. Calibers of choice for me is a 260 barrel from Bullberry at 15 inches.... deer, speedgoats and even elk. Recoil isn't bad and its a really accurate gun. My big caliber is a 338 federal in a 15 inch barrel from MGM. Its a hammer. I made the mistake of not putting a muzzlebreak on it. That caliber is powerful enough to do it all with ease... and after a practice session with it, I'm about wore out. It has "stout" recoil.

Holsters are a very big deal... in my opinion, it makes all the difference. If you go with a hip carry type holster, you in for a struggle. With a revolver, an alaskan guide chest carry rig is the way to go. Galco makes them that accommodate scoped revolvers and it is a good setup. For the Encore setup, I attach the holster to my pack and carry the gun that way. I tried carrying slung across my chest but for me its too bulky and aways seems to be in the way.

Your 454 is a great caliber and will do it all. I suspect you'll put a scope on it eventually and maybe do what I did and put a scope on it with too much magnification initially. The thought in my mind was that a scope with higher magnification will give me more range. That thought is a obvious mistake. If you want to extend your range, you need to go with a bottleneck rifle caliber cartridge... then you can realistically extend your range beyond 300 yards if you practice. Pistol caliber cartridges are a short range proposition for hunting. For your 454 I would go with the lowest mag scope like a 2x and certainly no more than a 4x and thats pushing it.

All this comes with the caveat that the recommendations given by me are worth exactly as much as you paid for them... but they are my experience and I hope they can help you in your journey.
 
I have a SRH in 44mag and a 460xvr....both scoped. The xvr is as heavy as a rifle and should not be shot without hearing protection. The SRH is heavy...but tolerable. I have some 629 and 329's that I really like for open sight hunting.

If the area is open to small bore pistol, my absolute favorite is a xp100 in 221 fireball. I can shoot sub moa to 250 on the right days and 1.5 on just about any day.

If elk were my focus, I'd not fear 44 or bigger and just focus on what I shoot well from every position.

I've sent 45lc hardcast over 30" deep at 60 yards and pushed a 240 through a few deer up to 80 yards and would shot an elk broadside at that range without question.
 
How you carry it is a big deciding factor. If I can't carry it on a belt, then I'd as soon tote a rifle. This I concluded after a couple seasons with a big, variable power scoped revolver. It's cool being able to lob them in at 250 or so, but I'm not carrying it all wrapped up across my chest anymore.

Some people really go for it, though, so you have to try and see for yourself.
 
I've used a Ruger Super Redhawk.44 mag with a Leupold VX3 2-8x30 for whitetails. I've only killed a couple of deer with it with the farthest being 100 yds.
I bought a TC Encore in .308 with a 15" barrel with a Leupold VX3 2-8x30. I've only killed a couple of whitetails, a mule deer, and a 78" antelope buck @ around 200 yds being my farthest shot.
I never really warmed up to pistol hunting, therefore, I haven't used them for hunting in years.
 
Back
Top