I agree with you. It's an individual choice, and hopefully a choice people make wisely. I've seen it more than once where people shoot at animals close to or at their "max effective range" and put a piss poor shot on an animal. Shooting at animals and shooting at targets are completely different. Lots of people just fall completely apart when shooting at animals. And a lot of them don't know it until it's too late and they've wounded and lost an animal, or two.
As long as people learn from their mistakes, it's a success. But I suspect a lot of the people on the internet who claim 60+ yard max effective range, have never shot at an animal that far, only targets.