I think everyone has to take their usage and experiences into consideration. If it works, it works. Some issues could also be attributed to scope mounting, rifle bedding and operator error problems and not the scope itself. I had no issues with a VX-2 LRD in a bedded, synthetic stock Remington 700 in 7mag. Leupold dual dovetail bases and Burris Signature rings. I passed that rifle on to my son in law and still no issues for the 3 or 4 years he’s hunted with it. I don’t even know how many deer I shot with that rifle over the years? Rifle is a 1968 model. VX-2 been on it since the scope was bought new by myself.
With that said, I’ve noticed what’s happened in recent years, lightweight and less durability trade off is obvious. These happened to two of my friends that I hunt with. In the last 6 months, one Muzzleloader scope, loss of zero, cannot return to zero, less than two years on a 12ga semiautomatic shooting slugs, purchased brand new. Leupold repaired it and sent it back. VX-3HD purchased new 12/24 and zeroed for upcoming Axis hunt this past April. Friend took a spill and dinged the objective bell. A quadrant in the scope fogged. Sent back and Leupold repaired it. Ding is there but scope is clear again. The warranty still holds up.
Not a hater, just facts. The VX-2 will remain as it has proven to be durable in that setup. Including the yearly air travel, shuttle, ferry trip and return.