9 preference points doesn't get you into some of the areas it used to even a few years ago. I know of several guys over the last couple of years that ate tag soup after hunting LQ areas. Just drawing an LQ tag won't guarantee you a better experience.
If you are a veteran elk hunter, by all means you should strongly consider finding the right LQ area. If you aren't, splitting points with a veteran elk hunter in a general area may very well provide you with a better experience.
No shame in a guided hunt either if that's the route you feel is best.