Everyone is saying hunt till dark, but I wonder how many truly do it (I’m not questioning the people specifically on this thread, just in general).
Because I get where the OP is coming from. If you have a truck camp and you hiked in 4 miles, most of it off trail, then if you stay till end of legal light you’ve got a good 2-3 hours of busting brush in the dark to look forward to after a long day. That puts you back to camp around 10:30pm, still have to eat dinner, probably getting to sleep around midnight. And if you want to do it by the book, you need to be hiked back in 4 miles to where the elk are before legal light. To do that you need to be up at 4am and out the door at 4:30. I don’t know about yall, but I can do that for a couple days, but I can’t do it for 10.
When the OP says non- resident; what I’m hearing him say is - unfamiliar with the unit. Maybe even inexperienced, or some of his crew maybe is.
When I first started out I was completely new to this kind of hunting (grew up deer hunting in the south, deer lease, camp, ATVs, 200 yard walks down a trail to a ladder stand…) I hunted elk from a truck camp for several years because that’s what I was comfortable with. The mountains had hazards I was unfamiliar with (not predators, mostly 100 ways to fall and hurt yourself) and that seems way worse in the dark. So, around 4 pm or so, I’d start “hunting my way back to the truck”.
Anyway, I agree with all the posts here, I just don’t think it’s as easy as it sounds. It takes time to build up the confidence. Confidence in your abilities, in your gear, in your navigation skills. Until you have that, hunt the best you can.
For me, I got tired of wasting all my energy hiking in-and-out everyday. I also found that I was spending the very best daylight hours to hear bugles (the first and the last) hiking and not really hunting. So I invested in a solid but lightweight bivy set up and I now hunt off my back. I pack camp, 3-8 days of food, water purification, etc. when I find elk, I hunt them. When it starts getting dark, I make camp, eat dinner and rack out less than an hour after dark. And, I can sleep till about an hour before legal, enjoy a hot breakfast, and still break camp before shooting light. But I don’t have to be moving b/c I’m already where the are (or close to it). I’ll never go back. I can remember feeling that gnawing anxiety every afternoon, pushing me towards the truck to avoid hours of hiking in the dark. It’s so much more relaxing now, b/c I don’t ever have anywhere to be besides where I am. Also, if you put an elk down at dark, once you get him into game bags, you are done for the night. Move the meat away from the gut pile, then Go up the ridge a bit and make camp. Get a good nights rest and start packing in the morning.
Sure, you have to be in shape to carry the additional weight with you each day, but This type of hunting is so much more efficient for me. Huge benefit being that I’m now getting around 9 hours of sleep every night. That is so important for your body to grind out 10-14 days of an elk hunt. Many times the hardest part of sleeping is all the bugles I’m hearing thru the night keeping me awake! I’m also putting on much fewer miles in now. When I’m camping close to the elk I probably average 3-4 miles/day; whereas I was 8-12/day with a truck camp.
It’s a far better system for me personally, but it’s not for everyone.