What does this buck score?

[Mtaylor]

Ran into this guy 2025 archery. Didn’t get him, was just curious what you think he scores? Also and opinions on width?
I’m trying to get better at field judging.

 

[robby denning]

roughly 170

but IMO, score just insults bucks like that.

He's a big deer, just doesn't have G3s. If he had even avg 10" G3s, he'd be 190

Just a guess

 

[S.Clancy]

roughly 170

but IMO, score just insults bucks like that.

He's a big deer, just doesn't have G3s. If he had even avg 10" G3s, he'd be 190

Just a guess

That's what I'm saying, this buck is a no brainer for me.

 

[elkman224]

He scores a spot on my wall!

 

[BasicUtahrd95]

Sweet buck! Love those giant front forks! I killed a buck very similar to that guy a couple years ago. The one I got has his g3 on the one side though. He didn't quite hit 190" and was just over 30" at his widest.

 

[AHayes111]

With out back forks and short browtines , he is way more impressive than score would indicate. I think 170 gross is real close, and upper 20's wide. That is a fine buck and headed for the wall for just about everyone.

 

[IrkedCitizen]

He only scores as wide as his longest main beam. I don't think he has 30" beams. He might touch 180. Dead all day and twice on Sunday

 

[RockAndSage]

Sweet buck! Love those giant front forks! I killed a buck very similar to that guy a couple years ago. The one I got has his g3 on the one side though. He didn't quite hit 190" and was just over 30" at his widest.

Nice buck...

 

[Tmac]

172 ish gross class is my guess. 28” ish outside spread. All guesses and he’s a gorgeous buck. Hope you find him this season.

 

[hersh2209]

Yep low 170s I'd say , great buck . mature

 

[Muleyczy]

Agree…high 160’s low 170’s

 

[MountainBuck200]

Fun to field judge "on the hoof". Any guesses on this guy? I took him the next day, my best typical.

 

[MountainBuck200]

Ran into this guy 2025 archery. Didn’t get him, was just curious what you think he scores? Also and opinions on width?
I’m trying to get better at field judgi

Ran into this guy 2025 archery. Didn’t get him, was just curious what you think he scores? Also and opinions on width?
I’m trying to get better at field judging.View attachment 1038481

Bomber buck. Shooter for almost anywhere, I would say high 160-low 170! Huge 3 point.

 

[graniteghost]

Fun to field judge "on the hoof". Any guesses on this guy? I took him the next day, my best typical. View attachment 1039069View attachment 1039070View attachment 1039071View attachment 1039072

I remember seeing your post on trophy bucks and bulls a few months ago. I’d maybe put him mid 80’s to 190. Curious to hear what you actually scored him at

 

[Mtaylor]

Sweet buck! Love those giant front forks! I killed a buck very similar to that guy a couple years ago. The one I got has his g3 on the one side though. He didn't quite hit 190" and was just over 30" at his widest.

Nice!!

 

[4weight]

I say mid 170's and 28" spread. He is a super cool buck that would not get a pass from me.

 

[Mtaylor]

roughly 170

but IMO, score just insults bucks like that.

He's a big deer, just doesn't have G3s. If he had even avg 10" G3s, he'd be 190

Just a guess

Your guess is better than mine! I really want to get better at it. So I just need to practice!

Thanks for your input!

 

[Bigbuckhdhunter]

165ish. My dad killed a big 3 like this that went 165.

 

[Mtaylor]

That's what I'm saying, this buck is a no brainer for me.

I was chasing a basket buck 4 point (really nice buck)! But when I saw this one he had my attention! Just have to find him again!