Water purification, filter or drops?

[ohhiitznik]

I currently have a MSR Sweetwater water purification system. Its not too heavy, I think 12 oz, but that could be an easy 12 oz's to shave off if I went drops/coffee filter route. What are you guys using for your drops/tabs for water purification? Do you have any trouble filling from stagnant water with the filter/drops?

 

[Evan Williams]

I am running a Hiker Pro filter. I have played with some MSR stuff in the past but keep going back to my ole faithful Pro. The water in system allows me to get water out of almost ANYTHING!! I have pulled from a golf ball sized pool an inch deep while my buddies kept hiking lower for a better flow. I know that a filter does cost me some weight and room over tablets or iodine BUT I can pump straight to my hydration bladder without removing my pack and I don't have to worry about chewing my water because of debris.

 

[david long]

I am an ounce counter......but leaving my water filter home is not an option. I will gladly pack the extra ounces. Check out the Rokslide Water Treatment article:

http://www.rokslide.com/2012-01-09-05-12-00/backpacking/144-backcountry-water-treatment

Water sources like this one below........pills or drops don't cut it for me!

 

[mailace]

I use iodine when i'm on the chase and my Hiker Pro filter when I'm at camp.

 

[Aron Snyder]

I'm running the Katadyn Hiker Pro and AquaMira drops.

If I'm heading into an area that offers clean water, I bring the drops, but if I'm heading into the unknown I bring the Pro.

 

[Aron Snyder]

I saw that photo in your book, Dave.....I've been in that situation and it blows!

 

[justin davis]

I use chlorine dioxide tablets. I have had to drink out of some yuck spots similar to Davids pic. Couple years ago Pronghorn hunting I ran out of water. The waterhole was about as gross as it gets. Dead birds and all. THe chlorine dioxide tablets kill everything thou!

 

[cmeier117]

I have the Aquamira drops and plan on getting a Hiker pro.

 

[flystrait]

I'm running the Katadyn Hiker Pro and AquaMira drops.

If I'm heading into an area that offers clean water, I bring the drops, but if I'm heading into the unknown I bring the Pro.

This is what I take into the backcountry.

 

[dotman]

Just use drops but do have a screen for my bladder that will keep most of the chewy stuff out, steri pen makes it.

 

[aggieland]

I use chlorine dioxide tablets. I have had to drink out of some yuck spots similar to Davids pic. Couple years ago Pronghorn hunting I ran out of water. The waterhole was about as gross as it gets. Dead birds and all. THe chlorine dioxide tablets kill everything thou!

Dang.... Justin Davis is the man.. Talking about nasty lol.

 

[AlpineAthlete]

Aqua Mira drops for me. I throw some baselayer type material over the hole of my hydration bladder while I fill it

 

[Matt Cashell]

Steripen Adventurer Opti. 3.5 ounces, prefilter keeps out the salad.

 

[Backpack Hunter]

Sweet Water Drops, and perhaps a coffee filter for keeping out the big stuff.

 

[JG358]

I use Katadyn Hiker Pro.... Worth the exrta weight IMO.

 

[BMB]

filter at the moment. MSR, gonna try the drops this season again, just don't know if i can get over it.

 

[les welch]

I'm running the Katadyn Hiker Pro and AquaMira drops.

If I'm heading into an area that offers clean water, I bring the drops, but if I'm heading into the unknown I bring the Pro.

x2 Exact same thing here.

 

[OR Archer]

Katadyn filter for me. I also carry tablets just in case something happens to my filter Ill still be able to treat my water.

 

[rckymtnguy]

Have you ever had any trouble with the Katadyn filter? I have had two of them now that failed when the little rubber valve on the output valve pushed through and then it doesn't get any suction. Generally I can push the little rubber valve back into place, but then I have to be careful how much pressure I put into the pump. Maybe I am doing something wrong, but I have had basically the same issue twice now.

I'm running the Katadyn Hiker Pro and AquaMira drops.

If I'm heading into an area that offers clean water, I bring the drops, but if I'm heading into the unknown I bring the Pro.

 

[dreamingbig]

I use Katadyn Hiker Pro.... Worth the exrta weight IMO.

Same here.