Curious what panniers you all run? I have limited experince packing in. Have been on a couple trips with good friends who are horse whispers i swear amazing what they do. I am looking to take it up myself but nervous I would say I know enough to get in trouble. With my buddies now taking care of their kids which is awesome I have had to go back to backpack solo or with my wife. Retiring in a year and will finally move to MT or WY and will be getting horses. Reason I ask on the make of the panniers I have only seen my buddies use the more open style tops and they cover with a tarp and use a double diamond knot for the life of me cant fig out i get more confused each time i see it. My other thought is just get two horses and saddle panniers and lead them in and still stay light. Not sure if that's a good idea cause while i am 50 now at some point be nice to ride two for my wife and I or son and lead one in. Guess what I am ultimately asking whats the best way to start in terms of horse and gear?
I'll give my very limited experience from someone who just did what you are thinking of doing. I got my first 2 horses 1.5 years ago. I've done a few hunting trips with them in WY and CO. 2 vs 3 is a personal/financial decision. It works with 2. 3 would be easier in alot of aspects. Looking at 2 vs 3. Increased cost for feed, shoeing, vaccinations, vet bills when they do something stupid, floats, gear/tack. Plus keeping 3 horses legged up vs 2. The biggest thing that kept me at 2 is transport. 2 horse trailers are easy to find at reasonable prices. You can run a bumper pull with any 1/2 ton truck. 3 Horse trailers are more expensive. Usually going to a gooseneck in a 3 horse or bigger. May need a bigger truck to pull a bigger heavier trailer. Plus it is a bigger trailer to get up and down those mountain roads (and try to turnaround). Lots of guys do it, For me, it would just add more to my stress level lol.
If you're always going to be hunting with a partner then 3 may be best (or 5 lol). 2 to ride, 1 to pack camp in. When you kill someone is walking out, or you're making 2 trips with the horses. 1 to ride, 1 for camp, 1 for meat. Then if you need to pack feed in that adds another horse. You can see how this can get out of hand quickly lol. For me personally, I'm just sticking with 2. I'll ride if I can and walk if needed. Walking in/out is still easier to carry a lead rope with nothing on my back. I can then ride out from camp when the horses don't need to haul anything.
I learned alot going down the horse gear rabbit hole. The guys who can manty and tie diamond hitches are incredibly talented! I'm not one of them lol. The bright side is that humans are very inventive and we tend to figure out how to make things as easy as possible for ourselves. To that end, smart horse people have created great ways to pack horses that require no real tieing skills for dumb newbies like me. Each type of pack saddle and panniers have pros and cons. I'll let you know what I chose and why for me.
I started with an over saddle pannier pack system. It worked well on my first and second WY trip. Gives the option of pulling the panniers off and then using the horse as a riding horse. Simple effective, but not quite as stable as a real pack saddle. Also you can pull the plastic inserts and then roll them up to store in saddle bags to be used when needed after a kill. Offers the option of turning your riding horse into a packhorse anytime. I do like the system, but the panniers will wear out. I ordered some ballistic nylon and 2" webbing and had a local seamstress reinforce the bags with additional liners and edge protection. Should last forever now.
Carry everything you need in the TrailMax Pack-A-Saddle from Outfitters Supply. This saddle pannier pack system is detachable and can be easily adjusted.
www.outfitterssupply.com
I did purchase a real pack saddle this summer and used it for my CO trip this year. Custom Pack Rigging. I went with the Hooks style solid arches #5. You can run decker or sawbuck style bags on these. The adjustable part means this saddle should work for almost any horse you get. Nice not to need a bunch of pack saddles to fit different horses.
I went with harness #39. I prefer synthetic Beta material. Less maintenance and should last forever. The owner is very helpful. I called and he walked me through what would work best for my gear and style of packing. The over saddle panniers above will work just fine with this pack saddle. Again giving you the option to use them on a dedicated pack-saddle or as the over-ridding saddle option.
http://custompackrigging.com/pack-saddles/
Outfitter supply also offers this saddle. But only with all leather harness. For the same price you can go direct to Custom pack rigging and get the Beta option.
https://www.outfitterssupply.com/Pr...uilt-by-Outfitters-Supply/productinfo/WPS600/
I do like and want a set of the hard bear-proof panniers. Here is the link to the economy version. These have screws in the lid for removal. They function the same as the more expensive ones, just more hassle to open/close. These can only be used on a pack-saddle setup, not with a riding saddle.
http://www.outfitterspackstation.com/beprpa1.html
What I would like next is this hard pannier. Easy access, just costs a bit more. Since I already have the over saddle system I couldn't justify spending another $500 for hard panniers at the time.
Keep important items and snacks safe with TrailMax Bear Proof Pack Panniers. These TrailMax panniers also come with rain covers for extra protection.
www.outfitterssupply.com
This is my limited experience opinion. There are alot of very knowledgeable experienced horse people on this forum! Hopefully, they will chime in and give you better advice. I just figured I would share some of what I learned having just gone down the road you are thinking about. At the end of the day, there are alot of options and they all will work. It will depend on your personal preference and what works for you.
Chase