Stephan Lake Lodge - Hunters Be Aware

SCFHunter

FNG
Joined
Nov 5, 2019
Messages
7
Location
Whitefish, MT / Orlando, FL
We booked our Moose hunt with Stephan Lake Lodge in December of 2020 with an initial scheduled hunt in 2022.

My daughter was pregnant and due in 2022 so in October 2021 we rolled over our hunt to 2023.

We provided payment in full on November 1, 2021.

Our Guide – Outfitter Contract indicated a lodge arrival date of September 3rd and departure date of September 16th.

Our Guide – Outfitter Contract was defined in writing as “Two 1 x 1 guided hunts simultaneous”

Our Guide – Outfitter Contract clarified in writing that bush plane flights during the hunt were included with schedule dependent upon weather.

Our Guide – Outfitter Contract clarified in writing that “(hunters may be combined in one group after moose harvest if preferred by hunters)”

Unfortunately, on December 5, 2022, the Outfitter notified us that they only had availability for August 25th thru September 3rd, irrespective of our fully paid contracts with September hunt dates specified. We reluctantly accepted the earlier dates.

On December 13th, 2022, the Outfitter e-mail correspondence indicated “We will have planes in the air up until the 24th of August scouting for animals. This will give us the best chance at placing you guys in a prime spot.”

This did not happen, and it is our understanding from our packer, registered field guide and master guide, that no scouting was done prior to our hunt.

According to our field guide, our field guide had never met our master guide and our field guide had never before hunted in the Guide Use Area we hunted.

On February 26th, 2023, the Outfitter indicated that our Master Guide was xxxx xxxxxx, and he would be in touch with us in the spring.

On June 15th, 2023, the Outfitter indicated; “You will need this information: xxxx xxxxxx is our Registered Guide Lic # xxxx City: xxxxxx xxxx State: Alaska.”

On August 13, 2023, the Outfitter e-mailed;

“Scott, We will be meeting you in Talkeetna on the 23rd when you sign your hunt records with xxxxx. We can take anything you don't want to bring in the field with you and have it at the lodge when you come back. More than likely you and your son in law will be at different camps and can meet back up at the lodge. We are doing some scouting this week”

Our guide and our packer indicated that there had been no scouting that they were aware of for the areas we were flown in for our hunt.

On August 21st our Outfitter e-mailed;

“Scott and Ryan, I have some bad news. I had you scheduled with two guides, xxxxxx xxxxxxxx and xxxxx xxxxxx for your upcoming hunt. Unfortunately, xxxxx took a very bad spill at work and deeply bruised his thigh muscle. It isn’t broken but he is instructed to stay off of it for at least 7 days or until the intense pain subsides. I know this not the news any of us want to hear but unfortunately this does happen in the guide industry. xxxxxx, is lined up and excited to take you both along with an experienced packer, xxxxx xxxxxxxx. He is a seasoned Alaskan guide and knows the area well.”

According to our field guide, he had never been in the area we flew into, was not aware of any scouting in the area and had no topo or aerial maps of the area.

According to Alaska Professional Licensing, xxxx xxxxxx does not have a license for the Guide Use Area we were hunting in, nor any Guide Use Area in Game Management Unit 14. Likewise, our Guide in the field, xxxxxx xxxxxxxx does not have a license to conduct hunts in the Guide Use Area that we were hunting in.

I assume that this is the reason our Outfitter contracted with xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx to be our Master Guide, as he has a license to conduct hunts in the Guide Use Area and Game Management Unit we were hunting in. Unfortunately, xxxxxx had never met xxxxxx xxxxxxxx and did not even know xxxxxx'x Guide License # until the day we flew out to the field.

It is also worth mentioning that our packer and guide were not provided with any type of bear fence and food items were stored under an open tarp and in the guide’s tent. Not surprisingly, bears entered our camp on two occasions, destroying and damaging tents and food products.

All of the above is written to give a clear understanding of the lack of proper planning and communication for this scheduled big game hunt and the unmet representations from our contract and written correspondence.

We paid $60,000 for two 1x1 hunts with bush flights in the field included.

We received one 2x1 hunt with only one transport to and from the field with one guide and one packer.

We paid for two charter flights to/from the Lodge for a total of $3,000, which we did not receive.

We were not offered any refunds, even after courteous request.

This post is written so that other hunters are informed and aware.
 

Adamsfj

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 25, 2018
Messages
150
Location
Oregon
Thank you for sharing. I saw them a PNW sportsman show and almost booked a hunt with them. so glad that I didn't now!
 

RS3579

WKR
Joined
Apr 2, 2020
Messages
1,259
They were playing you from the very beginning. They knew what they could and could not provide for you and didn’t care. They wanted the $$$ and that’s all that matter. They used the old “truck broke down excuse”. They less they provided the more $$$ for them. Sorry to hear about your experience. Too much $$$ for that to happen.
 

AKBorn

WKR
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
681
Location
Tennessee
This is the type of story that makes the "industry standard tip for guides is 15 to 20%" comments in the Guide Tipping thread (in the general discussion forum) so laughable. In my opinion there are more outfits like this than there are top-notch outfits in the current Alaska landscape. Not an abundance of Joe Want or Max Schwab type guides out there today.

Really sorry that you went through this.
 

Scottf270

WKR
Joined
Sep 26, 2017
Messages
649
Location
Missouri
Guided hunts are headed further down the crapper. Most over promise and under deliver. When I see the size of animals guys are paying thousands of dollars to kill I shake my head.

Even the best outfitters are hesitant to sell fewer hunts for the benefit of the resource. Some outfitters are selling additional hunts to make up for COVID. A well known NWT outfitter is booking 1/3 more sheep hunters per year to catch up on lost COVID hunts and revenue.

I would encourage the op to spell out the names of all involved if his story is true. Anyone who booked or was used to contract your hunt deserves the feedback. Word of mouth is how we hunters can out the shady operators.
 
Joined
Jun 15, 2016
Messages
2,850
Wow, I almost booked a hunt with them a few years ago. So glad I didn’t, and sorry to hear about your experience
 

Broomd

WKR
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
4,282
Location
North Idaho
I would raise hell about this everywhere and anywhere i could, 'courtesy' be damned. I'd rent a space at the sportsman's show just for a poster to outlay this scam that happened.

$60K is an insane amount of money and there would be a refund or replacement hunt given or that outfitter wouldn't rest.
 
Last edited:

Brian77

FNG
Joined
Aug 30, 2023
Messages
35
Very sorry. That's an incredibly frustrating situation. Thanks for sharing
 
Joined
Sep 7, 2023
Messages
1
Thank you for looking out for the rest of us. Makes me sick to my stomach they treated you like that. Take care and best of luck in the future.
 
Joined
Jan 6, 2014
Messages
965
Location
AK
@SCFHunter
On August 15th, I received a message from the purported owner of this outfit looking for a guide with the reasoning that he had a "moose guide back out at the last minute."
If the registered guide that you contracted the hunt with and signed the hunt record was not registered to conduct hunts in that particular Guide Use Area, I'd suggest immediately contact the Big Game Commercial Services Board and file a complaint.
There are too many fly by night, dishonest outfits in this state that give all guides a bad name.
 

CLP

FNG
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
58
Location
Denver
I sheep hunted here last year and it was a complete disaster of an operation. Guide was a young kid who had never sheep hunted. Dropped us on a lake where no sheep were present. After hiking our guts out for 5 days and no sheep they wanted $5k+ to move us into another area. The old owner sold it right before the hunts last year to a new group that have no hunting experience. They have only done commercial fishing.

The irritating part for me was the fact that they flew the next sheep hunted into the exact same spot I was in…
 
Joined
Dec 13, 2023
Messages
14
@SCFHunter
On August 15th, I received a message from the purported owner of this outfit looking for a guide with the reasoning that he had a "moose guide back out at the last minute."
If the registered guide that you contracted the hunt with and signed the hunt record was not registered to conduct hunts in that particular Guide Use Area, I'd suggest immediately contact the Big Game Commercial Services Board and file a complaint.
There are too many fly by night, dishonest outfits in this state that give all guides a bad name.
From the sounds of it, a master guide registered for the area signed the contract for Stephan lake which is a common practice. Understandably op is very upset but from what I gathered of the contract portion of the story is they did it all legit. I seen the advertisement from Stephan lake as well beginning of last season.
 
Top