Skyscraper 2P vs Niak/Rogen

[ElkAddict26]

I wanted to get some feedback on these tent options. I am looking for a 2 person free standing tent. I like the idea of 4 season use but not necessary. Durability and interior room are very important to me. I was hoping to be closer to the 4 pound mark, even though skyscraper and rogen are closer to 5 pounds. Look forward to hearing any feedback you guys have.

 

[Turkeygetpwnd38]

Hille Niak is a great tent. It’ll come in around 3 1/2, not a true 4 season but will take you 3+. I wouldn’t call it a 2 person tent though. Plenty of room for one person and gear. Only one I have experience with on your list but my favorite tent.

 

[North61]

The Skyscraper 2 has much lighter fabrics especially in the floor. The Rogen would be more durable....however the Rogen has screen doors... not the greatest feature in snow. Room is similar. Great tents both! The Niak isn't really a two man, but roomy for 1.

 

[thinhorn_AK]

I want the sky scraper personally.

 

[carsonkeys]

Interested in the same. Specifically for sheep hunting. Both have had more time on the market and I’m hoping to hear more reviews.

Bump.