I was gifted an expensive, slim, fashion brand wallet that fell apart in a year or two. Replaced it with a Saddleback Leather that is 10+ years old. You'll get tired of the wallet before it wears out.
I have an everyday leather wallet I get from Coach and a hunting wallet. My hunting wallet is a cheap nylon wallet from Walmart with velcro to keep it from opening up. I keep my id, hunter safety card, credit card and some cash but try to keep it to a minimum. I like it because it is pretty slim and nothing can fall out of it but carries everything I need.
i have the trayvax. i find myself being lazy and not putting my cash or my cards in it. then i pull my phone or even my wallet out of my pocket and my cash or my cards come out with it, fall on the ground and I lose said card or cash....