What all did you end up taking and ditching in the clothing department? Sounds like an adventure and a life changing trip, thanks for sharing.
I took 3 pair of base layers. One did not leave the tent and was for sleeping only. I rotated the others and tried to somewhat dry them in my bag. Still, they never got better than damp status. Fun to put on on a chilly morning!
I took one Sitka Traverse shirt, and ditched one that I had planned on bringing. Wished I hadn't. Could have used it.
I ditched my Pendleton wool shirt.
I took the Jetstream vest. Wore it once over base layers and under rain gear and it got so soaked with sweat that it was never usable again for the rest of the trip. That was a waste.
Wished I had taken just a simple fleece jacket.
Took a Sitka Kelvin Lite jacket which was nice around camp and while standing under a tarp for warmth, but too hot to hike in. I was still glad to have it. I also kept it in my bag with me and stuffed it into cold spots.
Took one pair of Sitka pants that never got worn. Was always just base under rain gear. Got cold standing still, but too hot to wear anything more while hiking. Would have like to of had some light puffy pants for sleeping and/or warmth around camp.
Took 4 pair of socks and wished I had more. One pair never left the tent and was just for sleeping. The rest were soaked through. My boots never dried out so putting on wet socks, while it sucked, was not really a big deal. Dry ones would have turned into wet ones immediately anyway.
I gotta figure out something for next time with my footwear. All but a couple of the guides wore plastics (Koflach/Scarpa) and glacier socks at times. I'm going to try those out before the next run and see if I like them. Another love/hate thing. All I know is my guide scrambled like a goat himself over stuff that I had to carefully pick my way through.
What I did right was to leave the one pair of socks and base layers inside the tent. My sleeping bag got wet towards the end of the trip. Crawling in with dry base layers was a must. I don't think I honestly did anything wrong with my gear choices, it was just really extreme weather, even for the area.
And ultimately, what I did right best was my fitness level. I felt fine the whole time. I was never sore or excessively tired. I actually impressed myself. Tons of leg work and a lot of weighted stability training helped big time! You are constantly straining for balance on a goat hunt so working those wierd little balance muscles in your legs is so important. Squats and lunges are good too, the big stuff gets you up the mountain, but the abductors and adductors keep you on the mountain.
Some things I will surel take next time:
A bivy sack. So what if your tent leaks! Instead it was a major source of distress for me.
Some chemical handwarmers. Toss them in my boots at night to help them dry out, and just general comfort. I found great peace in warm things on this trip as they were so few. Stuffing my mountain house in my jacket while it absorbed water was pure pleasure for 10 minutes!
HH Impertech pants, for the aforementioned reasons.
And then the boot thing remains to be seen. Different leather treatment? Different boots? Plastic boots? Waterproof socks of some sort? I have 2 years to work this out.
Anyhow, if anyone is considering a trip of this nature and wants to go over gear, let me know and I'd be happy to go into more detail.