The club I belong to uses Rinehart targets and they take a beating pretty well and inserts are easy to replace. Apple buck is fun to shoot but they have a lot of different deer targets that all seem equally well made (including mule deer ones if that’s what you’re after).
Rinehart. But when it comes to deer targets you have to pay attention to which foam you are getting.
You want the same foam that is in the 18-1 so you can remove your arrows in cool weather without a winch or a come-along.
I've got a small 3D course in the woods behind my house and my best target for longevity and arrow pulling is the Rinehart large black hog (Razorback). It's going on 14 years all outside. I've got multiple Rinehart whitetail deer targets around a treestand and some of them have the bad foam. You can loosen up the foam for arrow removal by full length stabs with a fixed blade knife (think Jaccard meat tenderizer).
For a Rinehart deer target be sure to get the best doe target within your budget. Rinehart has gone insane on antlers, you pay a premium for them and they don't help your shooting.
Deadnuts Targets are PROUDLY manufactured in the USA. They are printed on Fluted Polypropylene for strength and durability and in high definition so you can get the most life like experience while shooting. In addition, all our targets are matte finished to avoid glare.