Mike Islander
WKR
My suppressed 22 with sshp’s is far quieter than any pellet rifle I’ve ever shot. Especially one that’s powerful enough to kill a squirrel at reasonable range. I’d go with a bolt action though. Cleaner shooting and less noisy with the action staying closed. I’d also challenge the comment that suppressed 22 will spook deer. That’s not been my experience at all.
You can hold the bolt shut on the 10/22 with all ammo, and low velocity is even easier. I think spooking the deer depends on where they are when you shoot and the time of year. If they're spooky near the end of the season and approaching a feeder (legal in SC, and about all we can do with our thick woods), shooting suppressed might spook them IMO. Our bucks can literally go nocturnal near the end of the season. In any case, I'm not going to shoot squirrels while deer hunting. But if the OP wants to, I say go for it. Squirrels are some of the best tasting game meat in my opinion.