Seems like we are missing info.
I would want to know all the specs: draw length, draw weight, arrow weight.
Then a picture of the Op at full draw just to make sure everything looks good.
Sent from my SM-S918U using Tapatalk
This is where I'm at. Something is wonky or some important info is missing.
Are you using a really heavy arrow setup, or really slow setup?
You're trying to sight the pins in to work with a sight tape that's already on the sight? A sight tape is picked out and applied after getting some pins sighted in.
If the sight housing is already as low as it can go without contacting your arrow/broadhead, just to get the top pin sighted for 20 yards, then you won't be able to dial the sight for further distances anyway. Instead of a sight tape all you'd need is a blank tape with one alignment mark on it.
With an arrow nocked and sitting on the rest, is it level, nock high, or nock low? What height does the arrow run through the Berger holes?
What is distance from center of d-loop nocking point to center of peep?
Zero fletching contact happening? If drop away rest isn't timed correctly, the back of the arrow could be hitting and getting kicked up, making the arrow nose dive out of the bow.