No Good Deal Goes Unpunished (Trying the 2011 Koolaid)

Joined
May 29, 2020
Messages
57
Lately I’ve been idly searching for a project pistol to monkey with on the days that USPSA practice isn’t as captivating as it should be. Lately there’s been a proliferation of 2011’s on the market, and that platform has caught my interest a bit as a potential subject for the higher level tinkerer. Unfortunately, as you’ll know if you pay any attention to 2011’s, they’re kind of like Porsches: Even the cheap ones aren’t, and there’s effectively no such thing as an “economical” part in the aftermarket.

So, although I would peruse the ‘net occasionally searching for something interesting enough to pull the trigger on, nothing ever grabbed my attention. You were either paying up front, or paying as you go with mods in this game as far as I could tell, so I shelved the idea. That is, until the fateful morning that I opened up my gun club’s monthly newsletter and perused the “For Sale” section.

There, listed under some half full boxes of hunting ammo for way too much (I’m not kidding), was an interesting ad: A used Staccato XL (previously STI, and their current “competition” model in their lineup) with a swath of accessories and extra magazines, for a price that wasn’t a steal, but wasn’t insulting either. Curious, I texted the seller for details. Everything seemed to check out, and upon our text conversation it became apparent that the accessories it came with came darn close to the value of the gun itself (higher end competition magazines, holsters, and magazine pouches).

After some back and forth, we agreed to meet at the club and he let me put a few mags through it. While, quite frankly, I wasn’t blown away by the gun, I was still curious. What can I say? I’m a sucker for a deal. I told him I would think about it over the weekend, which is when he offered to throw in a Trijicon SRO to the deal. There it was, my sign: He was motivated to move the gun.

(Or maybe I took my scanning of “Never Split the Difference” a little too seriously. Great book.)

After running some numbers, both on the gun and my financials, and asking a few friends more knowledgeable on 2011’s, I decided to throw out an offer. Much to my surprise, while he did not take my offer, he came down on his asking price enough that I knew I would be a fool to pass on the deal. With a virtual “hand shake” we set a time and place to meet up and exchange goods, and conduct the FFL transfer. A few days later, and there I was with my new-to-me Staccato XL with SRO in hand:

IMG_8763.jpeg


However, as I mentioned, I was looking for a project. For better or worse, that’s exactly what I got...

I knew the gun would need some work. It wasn’t exactly spotless, and the previous owner had installed a short trigger and extended magazine release that I wasn’t particularly fond of. I immediately set about doing a better inspection of the gun and making my plans. Unfortunately, I very quickly found a potential trouble area that I should have identified before purchasing:

IMG_8782.jpeg


I’m not sure how I missed this, but as you can see, the previous owner did (or had done) possibly the worst grip reduction job I’ve seen, and on a pistol that originally MSRP’d for more than many mortgages no less! While not pleased with myself, I resigned myself to the fact that this was the risk you take when you play the used gun game.

(He also had lost the trigger guard screw, but that's an easy fix)

Prior to either replacing the grip or throwing the gun out the window, I took it out to the range to function test the gun with my preferred bulk factory ammo, and every magazine it came with. Fortunately the gun functioned fine, which means I wouldn’t be wasting my time salvaging the grip situation. No photos of the groups, as the rear sight became to work its way loose. Good thing that wasn’t staying.

Remember when I said everything in this platform is expensive? I briefly flirted with having Staccato replace the trigger and the grip. Unfortunately, I was quoted, how shall we say, a whole Glock for the parts and work. While it might have been worth it, that wasn’t the spirit of the project. Fortunately, I found a source of factory blemished Staccato grips for a fraction of the new price (the only good deal in the 2011 space, it would seem), and pulled the trigger.

Next came the detail strip, which is required to swap out the trigger and grip. As I tore the pistol down (fortunately, just like everything these days, there are some excellent YouTube videos online about this, and no specialized tools are needed) I found that the gun, though wiped down on the exterior, was absolutely FILTHY under the hood. Like, it looked like it had been stored in a literal sandbox. This simple trigger swap became a deep cleaning mission. Nothing is ever simple.

IMG_8857.jpeg


IMG_8855.jpeg


IMG_8854.jpeg


Fortunately, after a good bit of cussing, scrubbing, and two attempts to reassemble the gun, it went back together without much fuss (especially for a platform this cantankerous). The original OEM medium length trigger does not fit as well in the new grip frame as the original, but that is to be expected, and there are ways to tackle this later should I choose to. The trigger is also, quite frankly, lighter than I would prefer, and will likely get tweaked a bit (or replaced with an aftermarket unit and tuned). Fortunately, the trigger is the only area where the fitting of the replacement grip is not as good as the first one, and it functions 100% as far as I can tell with basic function checks. It’ll do for now.

IMG_8867.jpeg


IMG_8862.jpeg


IMG_8875.jpeg


IMG_8874.jpeg


IMG_8873.jpeg


IMG_8872.jpeg


So I now have in my possession, despite fate’s best efforts, a clean competition grade 2011 with a SRO, and everything I could need short of a literal belt to run it in USPSA should I decide to. While I’m not head over heels for the platform yet, and I certainly don’t plan to sub out my Glock 34 for it in USPSA, I’m interested to put some rounds down range ASAP.
 
I shoot a semi custom 2011 in open in USPSA. Look for a Cheely steel grip or an atlas grip. You’ll thank yourself the more you shoot it with one.

I use vibratite on my grip screws to keep them from backing out. Works well for me.

I’ve shot a big match in Wyoming with a borrowed Staccato when my open gun broke a couple days before the match. They shoot well and you’ll like never be able to outshoot the gun, but as crazy as the price seems on the staccato those are the starting price point of LO guns with others like Atlas and Infinity beckoning a much higher price tag and incredibly smooth guns and good shooting.

Good luck with it. You’ll love it.IMG_5815.jpeg
 
I’ve seen a handful of guys point out that it’s common for a shooter to start on a Glock, “upgrade” to 2011s, get tired of cleaning mags and replacing them at $70+, and then end up moving back over to Glocks. However that’s in a competition sense, where if you don’t want to compete against 2011s, you just pick a category in which you don’t have to.

Maybe I am fortunate in the fact that I haven’t had the spare money to make the jump yet. It’s on my bucket list to own one, but it’s not a high priority until I retire from my current job that has a ton of institutional inertia behind issuing Glocks only.

I have shot 2011s just enough to know, it would require a couple months of retraining to actually get better with one that I am with my Glocks. I can tell it’s an objectively better made gun, (more accurate, better trigger, etc) but with my currently built habits and muscle memory I shoot a Glock better on timed and scored drills.

Nice to see there are some deals to be had for the right buyer though! lol.
 
I’ve seen a handful of guys point out that it’s common for a shooter to start on a Glock, “upgrade” to 2011s, get tired of cleaning mags and replacing them at $70+

On the issue of 1911/2011 reliability, from personal experience, I went into Sig 226s/229s back in the 1990s because I just couldn't get high-cap 1911s/2011s reliable enough to have complete peace-of-mind to carry them. Especially with the mag problems the 2011s and STI didn't work out until relatively recently. But I shot better with them, so it was frustrating.

I've recently come back around though - my Staccato C is more reliable than the 229s, but it takes many multiple thousands of rounds to see that, and I've seen Glocks crap out plenty to know the classic Sigs are more or less at the same level of reliability. No shade on Glocks, but I also just couldn't shoot them nearly as well as the Sigs.

Yet, I shoot better with the C than any other production gun I've ever had, and would absolutely stake my life on it. I wouldn't have thought I'd say that as little as maybe 2 years ago. Staccato's carry & duty oriented guns have absolutely solved the reliability issues.

That said, the more raced-out, gamed-out a 2011 build is, the more reliability problems you're going to have. But the same goes for Glocks and other modded guns. The biggest issue is to just know and maximize a given platform's limitations, and plan accordingly.
 
Back
Top