I shot the following broadheads into a virgin Rhinehart 18 today to see how they compared penetration-wise.
I compared these 100gr heads:
Woodsman Elite
Slick Trick Magnum
G5 Striker
G5 Montec
QAD Exodus Full
QAD Exodus Swept
On the first round all the arrows penetrated about the same with the slightest difference.
In order of deepest penetration they came outta the target in this order:
Exodus Swept
Slick Trick Magnum
Woodsman Elite
Exodus Full
G5 Montec
G5 Striker
But the Exodus Full collided with the Woodsman Elite in the target doing damage to two of the blades.
I replaced the Exodus Full broadhead and shot again…this time flipping the target over and shooting another virgin side.
On this round the arrows were still all pretty comparable in penetration; none did significantly better than the rest.
In order of deepest penetration they came outta the target in this order:
Exodus Full
Exodus Swept
G5 Montec
G5 Striker
Woodsman Elite
Slick Trick Magnum
All the broadheads used in this test were brand new, unsharpened and right outta the package. The Exodus Swept drew blood but that may have more to do with the way they are packaged than the blades themselves but they did “seem” the sharpest to me. But the damage to the one Exodus head surprised me. Glad the blades are replaceable.
So based on this completely unscientific and arbitrary test, all these broadheads performed about the same when entering a target of uniform density. They all flew accurately and none lacked any punch. I guess this simple experiment was inconclusive.