Mule Deer in the West like Whitetails in the East?

Jack321

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Apr 15, 2020
Messages
290
Midwestern whitetail hunter here, done several elk, and antelope hunts out west the last 10 yrs. Also had my fair share of whitetail hunting here at home in the midwest. Its in our blood.

Looking to do my first muley hunt fall of 2026.

East of the Mississippi is deer hunting is "throw a dart at the dart board and go hunt." (When looking for outfits.) The midwest is prime whitetail habitat to find a solid buck can go from big bucks in Iowa, Wisconsin, Illinois, Kansas, Indiana, Ohio, Missouri and everywhere in between and just about every outfit can increase your odds at punching a tag on a nice buck.

Theres 1000s of outfits from all these states if a guy wants to go pretty much anywhere and capitalize on a decent whitetail, they can.

In my opinion, I dont pay for outfits in the midwest. My home hunting land is good enough and I think its dumb to pay someone for the same thing I can shoot in my home state.

That being said. I dont live out west. I can't scout it (other than e-scouting), nor put the time in to know the land, how the deer move, where things are. Thats why I'm considering a guided hunt. IMO thats why I pay a guide--to do the things I can't do and use their knowledge.

My question is if the western states are like this? Meaning can solid muleys be found in pretty much any state, just pick an outfit and go hunt?

I mean I get Western hunting, 200 acres can be "solid deer habitat" in the east. And out west 20,000 is solid habitat. Again, I've done enough reading and my own hunting to understand Western Hunting. And I also understand "it depends on what kinda hunt you want?" (Back country, DIY, spot-n-stalk, truck, wall-tent)

And I obviously know I need a tag, points, draw.

I guess my main thing I'm after is a solid buck I can put on the wall.

I'm not after a "giant" though that's obviously welcome. I don't need a 30" spread, or 180+" with kickers and junk to the side or giant mass. Honestly--just like the size of a 130s" solid 8pt in the east would be 100% fine by me.

Theres a lot of eastern outfitters that have nice whitetails.

Is Western muleys like that?

Wirth 10-15 western states to look at, and 1000s of outfits to choose from and each one boasting giant pics of animals, its dang near impossible and looks all the same to me! (Just like an Iowa buck looks like a Wisconsin buck.)

Throw a dart at the dart board?
 
Since there is so many outfitters its important to tell them exacrly what you want. Do you want a guided hunt that someone just takes you to a mediocre deer and expects you to shoot it and leave. Tell some of these your "130 deer" would be fine might run you through like that. If you want to hunt "with" a guide and spend time glassing and getting a full western experience, tell them that also. There is a big difference in guides that "take you hunting", or "go hunting with you". If you dont like their responses to your wishes, move on down the list. There are plenty more
 
How old are you and do you have any health issues that limit your abilities to hike/pack? Do you want to hunt with archery, muzzleloader, or rifle?

Regardless of which method of take you prefer your best bet is likely Colorado in any unit west of I-25 that you can get a tag. Several units have high tag allocation and can be drawn with 0pp or be picked up leftover.

Personally I would not pay a guide. 2nd/3rd rifle season are 9 days each. Show up early with at least 1 full day (rise to set) in unit and then hunt hard for all 9 days. You'll likely take home a 150"+. Grind it out and don't let your mind break.
 
For a deer of that caliber I wouldn't waste my money on a guide. I'v done one guided hunt when I was younger and let's just say I wish I spent that money to go on 3/4 DIY hunts. I'm from PA and we go out west every other year for mulies now DIY on public land. Finding deer has never been an issue for us if you mentally have it to put in the time and miles. Depending on the state you can have vastly different hunts. From backcountry spike camps to road camps with short walks to glassing points. For the little experience I had with a guide I did not enjoy it. I felt like I was just along for the ride and took no part in the actual hunt or planning process.
 
Most general units in the west will get you a 130” mule deer with some effort. I wouldn’t hire a guide to do that for you.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This is the info I'm after.

I'm early 40s, decent shape (could always figure to lose some weight, right!) But I've done elk and antelope hunting out west. I have all the gear, clothes, rifle, etc. I'm no novice, but wanted to just understand if i could just pick a spot and hunt.

I feel like midwest whitetail outfits are all similar and give you a good opportunity to punch your tag.

Id bet that guys in WY would never pay an outfit to hunt muleys cuz its their home state. And they muley hunt every fall.

I'm that way with Whitetails. I would never pay to go hunt in a neighboring state a whitetail because I can hunt em in my own state.

But I dont live out west. So to me, thats why I am considering a guide.

But if I can find a unit with some public land, general tag and some grunt work, punch a tag, then I won't consider a guide.
I just figured a guide for access. One who knows the "lay of the land" because I cant do the prep work before hand.

But the general consensual I'm getting is muleys are similar to whitetail.....find a unit, find some public land, do some e scouting, and go hunt.
 
Back
Top