I've had about every Irish Setter boot made over the last 15 years. I always thought they made an "ok" boot however, they dont compare to the Hardscrabbles. I wear my Hardscrabbles from mid fall to early spring, hunting, hiking, fishing and even every day use. I'm very pleased with them. I use their Mountain Extremes for hunting as well. The more you wear them, the better they fit and feel. Great ankle support and the sole will be completely different than what you're used to. Give them a try!