Is/was backcountry backpack hunting a trend and fading?

Wprinkle

WKR
Shoot2HuntU
Joined
Aug 25, 2020
Messages
449
I will give a slight look into my background for perspective. I grew up in the mountains of Colorado during the “golden age” of backpack public land hunting. 90’s-early 2000’s. Then my backpack hunting experience was limited to mule deer then as shooting an elk back then consisted of sitting in the truck and waiting for the right one to walk to a spot you could pull the truck to. Big Muley’s required a bit more effort. Archery hunters made up the majority of the backpack hunters, with very few rifle hunters getting off the roads. A.L.I.C.E packs and Army surplus wool pants were high tech gear.

It seems with the popularity of archery hunting gaining a lot of traction, so did the backpack hunting. Not sure if it was a combination of mobile mapping apps and social media that fueled this fire but the timelines match. It was also about this timeframe wildlife management appeared to drastically decline in all most western states. More hunters chasing fewer animals created a need to backpack and hunt deeper and deeper.

Shortly after, the hunting industry collectively positioned elk hunting to become the pinnacle of western hunting. Specifically, backcountry archery elk hunting. Archery backpack elk hunters were the industry appointed royalty of the hunting world.

Now my observations over the last couple years. (I am stuck in point creep purgatory, so the mass majority of my hunts are OTC/general unit easy to draw second choice units) It seemed that at one point with EVERYONE backpack hunting, more for InstaLikes than for elk IMO, the prime spots were either deeper than reasonable or more front country. But I have started to notice a major trend of “backpack” hunters day hunting. Fewer and fewer hunters past the 2-mile mark even when there is a sea of orange and no elk. There are the seasoned guys who regularly find success, and the new to hunting and or backpack hunting crowd still getting after it. But that crowd is much smaller than ever.

IMO this is the fad fading. Gear is getting more and more expensive, tags are expensive, and its hard ass work BEFORE you even pull the trigger. Success isn’t achieved during the hunt, success is achieved in the previous 300 days a year before the season even starts. I think low success rates, discovering how hard it really is, the overall expense, and the lack of ability or desire to dedicate yourself all year contribute to the fading of popularity. I don’t follow influencers or have a social media presence but it seems that side of the industry is fading as well. Most of the guys I am around that fell into the aforementioned Hunting Royalty class have traded bows for rifles and tents for campers.

What is everyone else’s take in this?
 
I think you may just be observing the generational trend of the people you know getting older. The hunting specific backpacking gear market has exploded since the Golden Age period you have described. Think about it, Exo packs hit the market in 2014. Stone Glacier 2012. Kuiu 2011. Sitka Gear 2005.

I think that backpack hunting as total solution to Western Hunting may have peaked simply because it became so popular that it became impractical for first time hunters to rely on it as a solution to finding animals, but the practice remains as popular as ever, probably more so if you look at total numbers.
 
I think you may just be observing the generational trend of the people you know getting older. The hunting specific backpacking gear market has exploded since the Golden Age period you have described. Think about it, Exo packs hit the market in 2014. Stone Glacier 2012. Kuiu 2011. Sitka Gear 2005.

I think that backpack hunting as total solution to Western Hunting may have peaked simply because it became so popular that it became impractical for first time hunters to rely on it as a solution to finding animals, but the practice remains as popular as ever, probably more so if you look at total numbers.
Very good points. I was talking more general observations not people I know. And in the lower 48, Alaska is Alaska. But I will agree that the companies mentioned above are "products" of the golden age (pun intended) and I am sure sales are still high. No matter what style your hunting is, good gear and packs are essential and they definitely filled that void. But specifically I am seeing less and less guys that live out of their pack and hunt for 5-10 days. Not saying its good or bad as I have had to adjust my hunting tactics a lot as well over the years. Just what I observe in low quality hard to hunt units. Agree those companies all started out as "light weight high performance gear for the backpack hunter" but 2 of them and probably a third soon have absolutely shifted to include all types of hunting. Maybe a sign of the trend fading or smart business, I don't know. Also not to call us old but even though 2012 seems like yesterday it was almost a decade and a half ago.. haha maybe it is as strong as ever
 
Seems to me it’s becoming more and more common to see threads here with the flavor of “we hiked in forever, didn’t see a thing, it was really hard; should I just hire an outfitter?”

Backpacking for elk is tough. It gets even tougher when a bull is dead 6 miles from the truck. Most guys never make it to the figuring out how much harder it gets when you kill one, and for the ones that do, many say “never again”.

The vast majority of people I know locally that say “man, I’d love to go on a backpack elk hunt like you do”, don’t have what it takes physically just to get into elk country, let alone get a few bulls out in a week.

I think we’re seeing YouTube vs reality play out in real time. The duck hunting fad waned. I think back pack hunting will too.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
What's wild to me is that when I was a kid I was the only person I knew who had ever been hunting 'out west' and 35+ years later....I still pretty much am the only person I know who hunts out west.

There's one other family I know, about 15 miles from us, that regularly goes out west hunting. Otherwise I'm seen as a weird eccentric dude that spends money hunting. For most people hunting is something they do 2-3 days per year in the off chance of getting some free meat. I have two other friends, one went for the first time this year and one goes for cow elk most years. But they're the exceptions.

It's difficult to reconcile that western hunting popularity has exploded in my lifetime to the point that the land is totally saturated with hunters, with the reality that virtually nobody (as a percentage of population) does it. It's a small niche.
 
The 90’s-early 2000’s were the golden years of backpack hunting? I wasn’t in the game then, but find it hard to believe your claim.

All tags worth anything selling out, people lined up around the block waiting for their opportunity. Not everyone is packing in for 5-10 days, cause we know you don’t have to.
 
Very good points. I was talking more general observations not people I know. And in the lower 48, Alaska is Alaska. But I will agree that the companies mentioned above are "products" of the golden age (pun intended) and I am sure sales are still high. No matter what style your hunting is, good gear and packs are essential and they definitely filled that void. But specifically I am seeing less and less guys that live out of their pack and hunt for 5-10 days. Not saying its good or bad as I have had to adjust my hunting tactics a lot as well over the years. Just what I observe in low quality hard to hunt units. Agree those companies all started out as "light weight high performance gear for the backpack hunter" but 2 of them and probably a third soon have absolutely shifted to include all types of hunting. Maybe a sign of the trend fading or smart business, I don't know. Also not to call us old but even though 2012 seems like yesterday it was almost a decade and a half ago.. haha maybe it is as strong as ever

I don't have any numbers to work with in terms of how many people are backpack hunting and how that % has changed over the last 25 years, but I do see a lot of backpack hunters locally. I see them at trailheads and out and about in the backcountry. I also see a lot of YouTube content around backpack hunting as well as questions and discussions in various hunting FB groups: "Headed West for the first time, going to backpack in until we find elk...." There was a book published in 2022 called "Becoming a backpack hunter" and the popularity of titanium wood stoves, certainly suggests backpacking as the primary use. Not to mention the popularity of small tarp tents from a variety of hunter brands. People aren't buying tarp tents for truck camping. And even on the hot tent front, there are much cheaper options than titanium if you are truck/base camping.

I personally backpack hunt every season, though it is only about 1/3 to no more than 1/2 of my time in the field hunting (I do backpack extensively in the summer for recreation). I think that backpack hunting is an unwise approach for hunters new to Western hunting, particularly if they lack extensive and recent backpacking experience. Its not the solution that many seem think that it is, BUT, I'd wager it is more popular now than it was in the year 2000, both in total numbers and % of people hunting.
 
Going out west to get free meat…….

This is funny to me.
Yeah. lol. Me too.

But that's exactly how people see it here. They wouldn't dare spend the money to go west; they just want to shoot the deer they saw in their garden. I guess on some level it's 'free' if you're a homesteader who shoots deer with the same AR you keep for home defense, and that's exactly what a lot of people do.
 
The 90’s-early 2000’s were the golden years of backpack hunting? I wasn’t in the game then, but find it hard to believe your claim.

All tags worth anything selling out, people lined up around the block waiting for their opportunity. Not everyone is packing in for 5-10 days, cause we know you don’t have to.
No I think he is pretty spot on, maybe even a little late, older buddies of mine were spiking out backpack style in the 80’s the stories and trophies they have are insane, would have been fun to see that in CO. Even in my personal experience the difference from 2014 to 2024 are stark. Western hunting is more popular, gear, information, ect has never been easier to obtain. I think some of the excitement over the backpack stuff might be waning… but really western hunting is the last place where men young and old can test their mettle and I think a lot of men crave that . Only other things like it military service in certain branches IMO
 
I have never noticed a shortage of backpack hunters however I’m young in the game overall. I regularly convince myself that hunting from a base camp would be more effective, and then every season I end up choosing back to hiking in.

What I’ve come to realize is I’m just enamored with topography and the adventure just as much I am the hunt. I also like to do things the hard way and am a slow learner per my wife.

I think what the reality is that there is a turnover of a certain % that try it and determine it’s too hard, and the next year there is a new guy full of energy to replace that guy.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
think what the reality is that there is a turnover of a certain % that try it and determine it’s too hard, and the next year there is a new guy full of energy to replace that guy.


Yea. Ultimately, all the tags still sell and the trailheads still get orange enough to be visible from orbit.

Then there's people like me, who accept that it will almost certainly just be an armed mountaineering adventure and accept it for what it is, and don't sweat actually killing something very much. Theres lots of us in the woods as well. We're there, but idk if id even call it hunting.
 
I don't really care if it's a fad or not... I'm just tired of seeing point creep make "easy to draw" units innacessible. YMMV.

I think that has less to do with type of hunting and more it is accessible now to more people due to information availability. The internet, OnX, Inreach, Google earth, etc all make the information right at your finger tips. That has lowered the barrier of traveling from TN to CO for example.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The internet and social media have made it easy. Maps and route finding is an app. Finding an area is easy, even in forums where areas aren’t allowed to be talked about. Getting a mountain rifle together is as easy as following 10 easy steps, buy this bullet, use this this rangefinder, this pair of binocs, these boots, this tent, and if you’re really one of the cool kids get this pack and these clothes. We walk newbies through how to prepare, how to organize a pack, what to eat, how to poop.

When everything is easy, there are more people doing it and competition is higher. Look at all the guys working their asses off for small deer, going way too far in for meat elk, or skipping around to a different spot every year. Hunting new areas used to be a real challenge, now it’s just a little more reading and asking the right questions in the right groups. Fishing forums will tell you the specific rock to stand on while fly fishing high country lakes miles from the trailhead so you can be a part of decimating what was an amazing fishing experience. We’re at the beginning of drones invading the back country, just like trail cams do today. Laws and rules are slow to keep up with such things so there’s little hope the situation will be anything other than an arms race. Buy the app that follows individual trophy animals 24/7 and paying based on antler size, is right around the corner.

In the 1990’s we rarely saw another tent up high. Backpackers didn’t like hunters and hunters didn’t like backpackers, and very little was written about backpack hunting. Hunting forums grew, websites grew, and a critical mass of guys interested in it paved the way for the flood of new products.

Every decade is different, and there’s no way to put toothpaste back in the tube. It is what it is. Is today better or worse? For kids growing up today it doesn’t matter, it’s all they know. Every generation thinks they invented the sport. Lol


IMG_0736.jpeg
 
Back
Top