I really like the CDS system on the Leupold scopes but the scope itself isn't trustworthy to me. I had to send my scope back because of major tracking and erector adjustment issues which they repaired.
What could be easier than ranging a target at 575 yards and dialing 575 and hitting it? In the heat of the moment I'd rather dial to the exact yardage and shoot.
what leupold model was that? leupolds are tried and true. in saying that i wouldn't buy anything under a vx3 though. you might have just got a lemon but that happens with a mass produced item. could be worse though and get a vortex and have to send it away no matter the model haha.
but in my opinion every scope has advantages and disadvangtages.
swarvo- nice glass, decent turrets but expensive
leica- wicked glass- expensive
leupold- vx3 and up generally are the ones to get. light weight, good turrets, decent glass, generous eye relief
nightforces- king of dialing turrets, good glass, bomb proof, but a boat anchor
vortex- mostly junk beside razor line.
huskemaw- wicked custom turrets, just ok glass, all around decent scope for price
steiner- another decent quality scope and fairly tough
wouldnt even consider nikon, bushnell, burris but thats just me.

choose a scope that fits your budget and hunting style.