Idaho Non Resident Mule Deer

WVOregon

FNG
Joined
Apr 23, 2026
Messages
3
A little bit torn on drawing unit 22 general deer as a non resident. Put it as a choice on the first non res draw and ended up drawing it over units that are not 2 pt restricted. Definitely learned my lesson in the draw process this year- Had I not been going strictly off the non resident handbook (where they don't list the antler restrictions) I wouldn't have selected unit 22 as a choice to begin with. Went into the first tag exchange today and got booted off the website (30 minute timer) with unit 3 in my cart before I could exchange. For anyone who has hunted this unit as a general tag- is it worth traveling 10 hours to hunt an antler restricted tag like this? There is always a (very slim) chance at a freak but I know for sure I not going to shoot a yearling forky either. And the hunt dates overlap with our blacktail rut in western OR.
 
Thank you, I will definitely try the second tag exchange, and will be applying for controlled as well. I am thinking I will likely still go no matter what, bird hunt across the river from that unit every year, and love the country. Definitely have learned my lesson with the first tag exchange process. Spent hours looking at other units that had left over tags, waiting in the que for a couple hours with a list of units I wanted to exchange to and one by one they got picked off. Eventually waffled too long on switching to a white tail tag in unit 3 which was not part of my initial plan and got booted off the site. Now kicking myself for not quickly pulling the trigger as it would have been nicer to not have the antler restriction. Appreciate the response.
 
Thank you, I will definitely try the second tag exchange, and will be applying for controlled as well. I am thinking I will likely still go no matter what, bird hunt across the river from that unit every year, and love the country. Definitely have learned my lesson with the first tag exchange process. Spent hours looking at other units that had left over tags, waiting in the que for a couple hours with a list of units I wanted to exchange to and one by one they got picked off. Eventually waffled too long on switching to a white tail tag in unit 3 which was not part of my initial plan and got booted off the site. Now kicking myself for not quickly pulling the trigger as it would have been nicer to not have the antler restriction. Appreciate the response.
If you don't get in by 10:05 or so, you're not going to get a decent tag. The online system is very late with the "live" sellout lists.
 
Turn the tag in by May 1 to get a 75% refund. Apply for controlled hunts, and try your luck at the remaining returned tag sales later in the year.
This is where I’m at with my tag, cant stomach missing the best part of blacktail season on the coast for the tag I got.
 
Back
Top