The best way to track is to make a good shot. That's where most tracking jobs begin - is with a poor shot. Learn how to shoot and you will find your dead animals. Most of the "i lost X" stories all begin with the perfect shot and a miraculously tough animal that defies biology. "I smoked him" turns into 3 days of misery grid searching the country side.
My attitude is that the only thing you can control is your shot. Every hunt has a shot opportunity and that's where you will make it or break it.
I agree with you in principle, but that isn’t really helpful to this thread. Whatever the reason you need to track is irrelevant, this thread is about tracking tips. You are 100% correct that most rodeos can be avoided by taking a “good shot” or a “better shot.” But I have personally recovered “miraculously tough [deer] that defy biology” and verified that the shot “should have put them DRT.” A mid-high lung shot that doesn’t affect the spine is still within the vital zone, and will usually, but not always, put them DRT.
To get back on track and not wander too far off the trail…
Tracking skill can still be a valuable tool before the shot. When I am still hunting, as I usually do, I have often tracked unwounded game surprising distances before getting a shot (and not just in the snow, when it is fun and easy).
And since tracking skill is heavily based on knowing the baseline, I think one area in which a lot of hunters set themselves up for failure is in avoiding their hunting grounds until opening day or in only walking in the woods before or after it’s light out or in sitting in a stand all the time. It’s hard to know the baseline if you aren’t in the woods.
I walk through the same land as often as possible throughout the year and still hunt through the same land day-after-day from the first frost (squirrel season) through the end of the rifle season. It’s never stopped me from being successful during the rifle season and I think a large part of the reason for my success is my familiarity with the woods (in fairness, I am also not picky, I shoot any legal buck unless it is really small-bodied). I know the baseline. I know which water sources are active now, which trees have the most acorns, which trails are most traveled, etc. I can tell that a deer has crossed the creek or been eating acorns last night because I know what those spots looked like the evening before. If all my hunting was done from a blind on top of a hill in the pasture, I don’t think I would be any good at tracking (unless I got a lot of practice by taking bad shots

).