How do you choose a unit for NR Idaho elk

Joined
Feb 2, 2020
Messages
2,901
I live/hunt in Utah and im considering hunting in Idaho for elk next year. I've never hunted the west as a non-resident, I'm very unfamiliar with the process of picking out a place to hunt where I've never been.

I'm wanting to either rifle or muzzleloader hunt and am fine with shooting antlerless. I want maximum chance to fill my tag, so bull or cow is fine. I live near salt lake, so staying out of the panhandle to shorten the drive is important.

I looked through some units on the IDFG site, looked at success rates, etc and I'm looking at the beaverhead elk zone, but not sure. It's the first place that caught my eye.

If you have some general info, warnings, things I should definitely know about that zone, please PM me. I plan on calling IDGF to ask about it too.

How do you guys go about picking a place for the first time? Are there any primary strategies you use? Just go off a list of priorities?
 
OP
H
Joined
Feb 2, 2020
Messages
2,901
Thing about Idaho is it's a shit show on how you get in the queue and what's left when you actually got in and go to check out.

Good luck

Sent from my SM-S926U using Tapatalk
Kind of like Utah's general season ALW elk tag sale 2019-2023? Or worse?
 

jonesn3

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jan 11, 2022
Messages
272
Have a list of options based on some key unit stats that are important for your style. Options 1 through 10. Depending on your random number, you might really have to take a shot in the dark based on what’s remaining tag wise. At the moment, I prefer opportunity in the form of %public land, size of the unit, and some form of population metric.
 
OP
H
Joined
Feb 2, 2020
Messages
2,901
After researching heavily for a couple of days, I came up with five different zones that I would consider purchasing a tag for if I had the opportunity to do so today.

To my surprise, every single one of those sold out in the first 30 minutes! And then I continued to watch in amazement as nearly all tags except for FC, LOlo and Selway sold out, not much longer than an hour or hour and a half. I was #8000 on my phone and #20000 on my computer, with no real intent to buy a tag. I just wanted to see what would happen and how quick they'd go.

I think I will just have to start researching routes into the deep wilderness since I do not know how to fully abuse the Idaho online system as some do.

Or I'll just continue hunting my own state haha
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2019
Messages
368
Location
Oregon
As flustering as my home state is to draw or hunt general elk units…….. my experience is you may be driving away from elk to hunt wolves. Only half of my group got tags for 24 we didn’t even log in this year.
 
Joined
Dec 3, 2024
Messages
6
After researching heavily for a couple of days, I came up with five different zones that I would consider purchasing a tag for if I had the opportunity to do so today.

To my surprise, every single one of those sold out in the first 30 minutes! And then I continued to watch in amazement as nearly all tags except for FC, LOlo and Selway sold out, not much longer than an hour or hour and a half. I was #8000 on my phone and #20000 on my computer, with no real intent to buy a tag. I just wanted to see what would happen and how quick they'd go.

I think I will just have to start researching routes into the deep wilderness since I do not know how to fully abuse the Idaho online system as some do.

Or I'll just continue hunting my own state haha
I was one of the poor souls silly enough to buy a Selway tag when my number came up. Now I have the daunting task of figuring out how to carve an elk out of that massive wilderness ridden with predators, on foot, and solo to boot.
 
OP
H
Joined
Feb 2, 2020
Messages
2,901
I was one of the poor souls silly enough to buy a Selway tag when my number came up. Now I have the daunting task of figuring out how to carve an elk out of that massive wilderness ridden with predators, on foot, and solo to boot.
I'll absolutely get a tag for middle fork or Selway at some point, but I'll be considering it more of an adventure than a tag filling mission.
 

Dixie

FNG
Joined
Jan 13, 2023
Messages
68
I was one of the poor souls silly enough to buy a Selway tag when my number came up. Now I have the daunting task of figuring out how to carve an elk out of that massive wilderness ridden with predators, on foot, and solo to
I’d recommend calling the local FS districts you plan to hunt about trail conditions as we’ve had some significant windstorms last fall in the Selway zones and with the current non-hiring of seasonal workers some areas might have limited access.
PM me and I can tell you trail conditions of the South end of the area,but definitely not where to find the critters.
Good Luck.
 

jonesn3

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jan 11, 2022
Messages
272
My buddy picked up a Selway tag pretty easily, one of the last zone available on his random number. New unit for him. Based on some information online looks like a difficult hunt to say the least
 

roadhntr

FNG
Joined
Apr 8, 2020
Messages
56
Why the need to hunt Idaho? The reason I ask is because I'm also from Utah and I'd never consider Idaho to hunt elk. Maybe Colorado but since there's already a lifetime of areas to hunt elk in Utah and it's a whole lot less expensive as a resident.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Dec 3, 2024
Messages
6
I’d recommend calling the local FS districts you plan to hunt about trail conditions as we’ve had some significant windstorms last fall in the Selway zones and with the current non-hiring of seasonal workers some areas might have limited access.
PM me and I can tell you trail conditions of the South end of the area,but definitely not where to find the critters.
Good Luck.
I'm still fairly new to the site so once I've earned my way out of FNG purgatory I will do that!
 
OP
H
Joined
Feb 2, 2020
Messages
2,901
Why the need to hunt Idaho? The reason I ask is because I'm also from Utah and I'd never consider Idaho to hunt elk. Maybe Colorado but since there's already a lifetime of areas to hunt elk in Utah and it's a whole lot less expensive as a resident.

Just to do something different. Different terrain, etc. also, Idaho actually has OTC firearm tags for cow elk. Utah, everything antlerless is a draw. Even archery.
 
Top