Has Anyone Cashed Out Their 401(k)?

HornPorn

WKR
Joined
Oct 7, 2020
Messages
413
Cashing out a 401(k): Would love to hear how old you were when you did it, how you rationalized doing it, how old you are now and if you are still glad you did or not?
 
The IRS makes it painful to withdraw/cash out a 401k for reasons other than retirement income from both a tax burden and penalty standpoint. The only instance I would ever consider this as an option would be if it fell under the IRS hardship distributions guidelines and I was looking at potential bankruptcy, truly a last resort option.

If I'm looking to scrape together funds, touching a traditional IRA or 401k account is going to be the last account on the list. This may be different for your situation if you're over 59 1/2.

One of my close hunting buddies cashed out his 401k after every job he left. His finances were a mess (camper loan, side-by-side loan, vehicle loans, home loan, paycheck-to-paycheck and frequently overdrawing his account) and is not an example I would want to follow for financial wellness.
 
The first example that comes to mind is someone I know of who cashed out their entire 401k to open a Crossfit box. The gym last about 4 or 5 years before closing shop. The equipment was liquidated for pennies on the dollar and I think they got stuck paying their lease for months after closing.
 
I withdrew my retirement when I left a job after 2 years when I was 24. It funded my move to a new state/job and starting over at 0 with my debts. It was like 12k in the account, $5500 to my bank account iirc. I would do it again to not have a dime sitting in a CA account.
 
I did back around 2009. I went out on my own building houses right before the crash. It helped me through that hard time but sure wish I had not taken the money out.
 
I'm 62, been retired near 10 years now and have only drawn from it once, but only about 5% of it. We haven't touched my wife's yet. With our SS and wife's pension payments, we're pretty much solvent.

If you had matching by your company, plan very well on how much taxes to take out on withdrawal.
 
I did recently, at least a good chunk of it to put a down payment on a house.

I don’t like that it happened..but it was the right move for the family. It will cost me approx 2-3 years in retirement age, maybe more.

If at all possible you should avoid it!
 
I did back around 2009. I went out on my own building houses right before the crash. It helped me through that hard time but sure wish I had not taken the money out.

Props to you. Not many own up to their mistakes. Most will rationalize their decision even if it was a mistake, myself included, as much as I try not to.
 
Ive taken small chunks out of it over the years and have always regretted it. I just used it to pay off debt. You'll get hammered on taxes and penalties for sure. I'd try and find another way. Mine are doing fine now but would be doing great had I not taken out of them. If it's current and you need the cash, you are way better taking a loan against it, as at least you are paying the interest back to yourself. Just my opinion though FWIW.
 
The problem with taking out of the 401k is not only the early withdraw penalty and taxes, its all the money you lose over the next 20, 30, 40 years of gains you would have had on that lump sum that you never get back. Even if you pay it back.

That adds up to A LOT of money by the time it's all said and done.
 
The IRS makes it painful to withdraw/cash out a 401k for reasons other than retirement income from both a tax burden and penalty standpoint. The only instance I would ever consider this as an option would be if it fell under the IRS hardship distributions guidelines and I was looking at potential bankruptcy, truly a last resort option.

If I'm looking to scrape together funds, touching a traditional IRA or 401k account is going to be the last account on the list. This may be different for your situation if you're over 59 1/2.

One of my close hunting buddies cashed out his 401k after every job he left. His finances were a mess (camper loan, side-by-side loan, vehicle loans, home loan, paycheck-to-paycheck and frequently overdrawing his account) and is not an example I would want to follow for financial wellness.
Your buddy likes to live dangerously.
 
I borrowed against mine to buy a boat. You have to pay it back with interest, but the interest goes to your account. It's not bad if you do that. There are some rules but it's pretty easy.
 
I closed out a retirement 401K equivalent from an old job and payed off a vehicle. It was small, even after taxes I still made more than I put in. I'm to young to say if I regret it, but no longer having a truck payment has helped with putting money towards the house.
 
Back
Top