Gut shot deer on public with private retrieval

Joined
Jul 20, 2022
Messages
77
Yesterday I went out for a 4th season mule deer doe hunt. First thing in the morning only a few hundred yards into my hike I spot a doe bedded down - too good to be true which proved to be the case. It took me a minute to confidently identify the doe 150 yards away as I was unsure if she was a tree stump or an actual deer. She must of caught my movement as she stood up and bounced a few yards away and out of sight. I slid over to another opening in front of the direction she was traveling to see if I could get another look and potential shot. She popped right in the opening and I tried to line up a shot using my trekking poles as a bipod. I take a shot and thought it was a good hit, but upon getting up to where I had last seen the doe my 'too good to be true' scenario turned into a hunter's nightmare. A massive splat of green lay on the ground - my first gut shot.

The amount of guts and hair where I shot her was pretty extensive and looked like she was pretty hurt. I sit down to have some snacks and give it a couple hours. I pick up her tracks and find a little bit of blood - not a lot but consistent every couple feet. The tracks are headed deeper into public land, but after a 150 yards or so she decided to head up and make a U-turn directly onto some neighboring private property. I hiked out and drove around to try to go talk knock on the neighbors door but the property gate was littered with signs of "NO trespassing". I tried to connect with some neighbors to see if they had contact info but no one answers.

I head home completely distraught. I get online and find a neighbors address, and phone number. I give them a call and they informed me they did not know their neighbor well other than providing me with their name and an alternative address. Another google search and I get a phone number. I leave a message but after a couple hours of no return call, I decided to go to their former address. A new home owner informed me he thought the previous owners moved out of the country - great {sarcasm}! I head home unsure what to do, so I called Colorado Parks & Wildlife to let them know of the situation. The wildlife officer let me know he could not go on or give me permission to go on their land without their permission - totally understandable. Nothing I could do but wait - 2:30am I get a call from the land owner and I answer. He asks some basic questions and grants me permission!!!!

First thing this morning I went back in and found my doe down not far from where her tracks left public. I do the gutless method and the meat seems to be in fair condition, minus some meat loss due to the crows helping themselves to deer breakfast. On my way out I was stopped by the a wildlife officer who congratulated me on my deer and doing things the right way.

Lessons learned: 1) Take your time with your shot - I feel like I could have been more steady when taking my shot but felt rushed since the doe appeared to be leaving. That being said, it wasn't worth it, and next time I would be more sure of my shot before taking it. 2) Give it time - I thought there was no way she had made it too far due to the extensive damage, but looking back I probably should have come back later in the evening. Maybe she would not have made it as far and I could have potentially pushed her onto private. 3) Always do the right thing. I was glad I knew better than to trespass on private property and do as much work as possible to identify and contact the land owner. It not only felt good to be able to harvest the meat from that doe, but also that I followed the appropriate steps to legally retrieve it. Very grateful for the meat I was able to bring home to my family!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3065.jpeg
    IMG_3065.jpeg
    458 KB · Views: 46
OP
M
Joined
Jul 20, 2022
Messages
77
@MountainMan83 did the landowner email you something in writing? Did the Wildlife Officer ask for anything, or just take your word for it?
I specifically asked the wildlife officer if I needed the land owner's permission in writing. His response "you just need his permission". So while he did not specify, i think it does offer some level of legal protection if for some reason the land owner did decide to press charges after giving verbal permission. However, in my case, I had a good trail of contacts I spoke to that would have backed me in court and I also had a phone call from him at 2:30am. The land owner also admitted I could have probably harvested the deer without him ever knowing, and he seemed to appreciate all the efforts I took to get a hold of him Couldn't hurt to get it in writing, but I think it would be a extreme case if a land owner gives you permission and then tries to press charges.
 
OP
M
Joined
Jul 20, 2022
Messages
77
You did everything right and beyond what most would do. Next move is to follow up with the landowner, Tell them you were able to recover the doe and where you found her. Also another thank you for giving permission.
Great point! The landowner requested I send him a text to let him know how it went, which I did immediately after getting home. I let him know I was extremely grateful for allowing me to enter his property to retrieve the deer and let him know how much the meat means to me and my family. The deer went about 250 yards onto his 80 acre property. I went in from public and exited the same way to minimize disturbance to his property. Also made sure to pick up and 'leave no trace'. Other than my tracks and the deer carcass (which he said I could leave), nothing was left behind. The land owner said this is the first time he has allowed anyone on his property, so I wanted to leave a good impression that ethical hunters are around to do the right thing.
 
OP
M
Joined
Jul 20, 2022
Messages
77
Good job on doing the right thing when no one else was around.
One thing I left out of my story above was this was my 5 year old son's first mule deer hunt (he has been hunting with me since 2 - grouse, squirrel/rabbit, and bear). At first I was so disappointed in myself for rushing the shot and 'loosing' the deer. Looking back, it was so meaningful and so many great lessons - as the saying goes you learn far more from your mistakes. My son got a lesson in tracking, waiting after shooting a gut shot deer, pursing wounded game until you find them, respecting private boundaries, ect. So while I could have pursued the animal over the boundary (albiet illegally), it was far more important that I did things right especially since he was the only other person around. He was crying when we got home because daddy wounded a deer and the deer was left to suffer. After recovering it the next day solo, I was able to explain to him what it means to make the right decision. He was on cloud nine and explaining to his mom how happy he was that we did not have to waste any meat. When I asked him if he wanted to go hunting with me again, he said of course. Could not be happier and looking forward to many more adventures with my little buddy.
 

mtnbound

WKR
Joined
Nov 8, 2016
Messages
436
Location
N. Idaho
One thing I left out of my story above was this was my 5 year old son's first mule deer hunt (he has been hunting with me since 2 - grouse, squirrel/rabbit, and bear). At first I was so disappointed in myself for rushing the shot and 'loosing' the deer. Looking back, it was so meaningful and so many great lessons - as the saying goes you learn far more from your mistakes. My son got a lesson in tracking, waiting after shooting a gut shot deer, pursing wounded game until you find them, respecting private boundaries, ect. So while I could have pursued the animal over the boundary (albiet illegally), it was far more important that I did things right especially since he was the only other person around. He was crying when we got home because daddy wounded a deer and the deer was left to suffer. After recovering it the next day solo, I was able to explain to him what it means to make the right decision. He was on cloud nine and explaining to his mom how happy he was that we did not have to waste any meat. When I asked him if he wanted to go hunting with me again, he said of course. Could not be happier and looking forward to many more adventures with my little buddy.

Great example for your kid. Good job!
 
Top