I agree with this to a point. The problem is most people don’t actually train when they run. If your truly training it means at some point you are going anaerobic and teaching the body how to use the oxygen it is taking in (v02max). Most people go out and run 3-4 miles and think that’s training. After a few weeks the body is pretty adapted to that. But doing say 10x200 meters with 200 meter jog in between and then a hard mile after the last 200 teaches your body to do something with that oxygen. I typically do two rounds of that workout.“Lungs” is probably just en expression in this case, but, just FYI, your lungs don’t actually get in shape, nor do they get “in shape” for altitude. That’s actually a cellular process in your bloodstream.
You do need an aerobic base for rucking, and running can help address that, however, once you hit a weight threshold (subordinate to your body weight and strength), usually around 25-30 lbs for most people, the energy pathway for climbing uphill with a pack is actually muscular endurance, of which running is fairly ineffective preparation for.
good call. There is actually a spartan workout that is burpees pull ups and no more then 2 miles looks interesting burppes suck hate them but man have a buddy at work once a week bangs out 300 and another day 100 for time hes a machine and shredded also in his 30s the bastardJust do burpees, they suck just like elevation gain does.
I agree with this to a point. The problem is most people don’t actually train when they run. If your truly training it means at some point you are going anaerobic and teaching the body how to use the oxygen it is taking in (v02max). Most people go out and run 3-4 miles and think that’s training. After a few weeks the body is pretty adapted to that. But doing say 10x200 meters with 200 meter jog in between and then a hard mile after the last 200 teaches your body to do something with that oxygen. I typically do two rounds of that workout.
Certainly, VO2 Max intervals is a type of training. But it is hardly the only type of training for which running can be used. Running for a period of time (would likely take more than 3-4 miles, more like an hour or so) at aerobic pace is training, and indeed valuable and arguably necessary training. Running at anaerobic pace is also training, but it's training a different energy system. Typically you would train VO2 Max on top of an aerobic base, and not too much, since: performance gains by increasing VO2 Max are minimal compared to those by increasing aerobic capacity; VO2 Max workouts are more stressful on the body, meaning that there is more pain for less gain; and VO2 Max is more influenced by genetics and is therefore not as trainable as aerobic base.
All that to say, you are probably correct that many or most don't actually train when they run. But I would disagree that all "true training" is anaerobic training. I would agree that anaerobic/VO2 Max training is important for performance at altitude, but in small doses and on top of an adequate aerobic base.
The 10x200 meters then a hard mile might be considered a Vo2 Max workout, but it's not one I've seen. I'd be curious where you pulled that from. (Genuinely curious, I have no dog in the fight and don't really care that you are doing it; good on you!)
The typical VO2 Max workout I've seen is several miles warmup followed by 10x400, or 5x800, with equal time rest between sets. The idea being to maximize time at VO2 Max. With shorter intervals, you are spending too much time in the interval getting your heartrate up to Vo2 Max zone and not enough time in the zone. With longer intervals or shorter rest you would get too fatigued to stay at VO2 Max heartrates for the equivalent period of time as with properly rested intervals. (Think about running at Vo2 Max all in one chunk, which wouldn't be as long as in multiple chunks with rest in between. You spend more total time in the zone with properly rested chunks.) Again, I don't have a dog in the fight, this is just what I've seen, and what I do, for V02 Max workouts.
I do a lot of different things for training. I did a 12 mile tempo on Monday at 5:45 mile pace and today was 14 miles easy at 7:10 pace. You make great points, I am just trying to say running is probably enough training for most People., but they do not do anything hard. The body adapts very quick to easy running. Easy running is amazing for teaching your body how to be more efficient, but it you want to have lungs you have to teach your body how to go anaerobic as well.Certainly, VO2 Max intervals is a type of training. But it is hardly the only type of training for which running can be used. Running for a period of time (would likely take more than 3-4 miles, more like an hour or so) at aerobic pace is training, and indeed valuable and arguably necessary training. Running at anaerobic pace is also training, but it's training a different energy system. Typically you would train VO2 Max on top of an aerobic base, and not too much, since: performance gains by increasing VO2 Max are minimal compared to those by increasing aerobic capacity; VO2 Max workouts are more stressful on the body, meaning that there is more pain for less gain; and VO2 Max is more influenced by genetics and is therefore not as trainable as aerobic base.
All that to say, you are probably correct that many or most don't actually train when they run. But I would disagree that all "true training" is anaerobic training. I would agree that anaerobic/VO2 Max training is important for performance at altitude, but in small doses and on top of an adequate aerobic base.
The 10x200 meters then a hard mile might be considered a Vo2 Max workout, but it's not one I've seen. I'd be curious where you pulled that from. (Genuinely curious, I have no dog in the fight and don't really care that you are doing it; good on you!)
The typical VO2 Max workout I've seen is several miles warmup followed by 10x400, or 5x800, with equal time rest between sets. The idea being to maximize time at VO2 Max. With shorter intervals, you are spending too much time in the interval getting your heartrate up to Vo2 Max zone and not enough time in the zone. With longer intervals or shorter rest you would get too fatigued to stay at VO2 Max heartrates for the equivalent period of time as with properly rested intervals. (Think about running at Vo2 Max all in one chunk, which wouldn't be as long as in multiple chunks with rest in between. You spend more total time in the zone with properly rested chunks.) Again, I don't have a dog in the fight, this is just what I've seen, and what I do, for V02 Max workouts.
I don’t want to sound like Cameron Hanes either here. I do not believe most people need to run more than 30 to 40 miles a week to be in very good shape with proper training. One thing that really irritates me is when people see someone wearing a certain shoe, so they go and buy it to run in and have no idea wether the pronate or are a neutral runner and then they wonder why their knees hurt or get an injury due to the wrong shoes. I wish there were more informative Instagram runnersCertainly, VO2 Max intervals is a type of training. But it is hardly the only type of training for which running can be used. Running for a period of time (would likely take more than 3-4 miles, more like an hour or so) at aerobic pace is training, and indeed valuable and arguably necessary training. Running at anaerobic pace is also training, but it's training a different energy system. Typically you would train VO2 Max on top of an aerobic base, and not too much, since: performance gains by increasing VO2 Max are minimal compared to those by increasing aerobic capacity; VO2 Max workouts are more stressful on the body, meaning that there is more pain for less gain; and VO2 Max is more influenced by genetics and is therefore not as trainable as aerobic base.
All that to say, you are probably correct that many or most don't actually train when they run. But I would disagree that all "true training" is anaerobic training. I would agree that anaerobic/VO2 Max training is important for performance at altitude, but in small doses and on top of an adequate aerobic base.
The 10x200 meters then a hard mile might be considered a Vo2 Max workout, but it's not one I've seen. I'd be curious where you pulled that from. (Genuinely curious, I have no dog in the fight and don't really care that you are doing it; good on you!)
The typical VO2 Max workout I've seen is several miles warmup followed by 10x400, or 5x800, with equal time rest between sets. The idea being to maximize time at VO2 Max. With shorter intervals, you are spending too much time in the interval getting your heartrate up to Vo2 Max zone and not enough time in the zone. With longer intervals or shorter rest you would get too fatigued to stay at VO2 Max heartrates for the equivalent period of time as with properly rested intervals. (Think about running at Vo2 Max all in one chunk, which wouldn't be as long as in multiple chunks with rest in between. You spend more total time in the zone with properly rested chunks.) Again, I don't have a dog in the fight, this is just what I've seen, and what I do, for V02 Max workouts.
I do a lot of different things for training. I did a 12 mile tempo on Monday at 5:45 mile pace and today was 14 miles easy at 7:10 pace. You make great points, I am just trying to say running is probably enough training for most People., but they do not do anything hard. The body adapts very quick to easy running. Easy running is amazing for teaching your body how to be more efficient, but it you want to have lungs you have to teach your body how to go anaerobic as well.