To reuse a quote I once read here; noons ever goes elk hunting and says, “I was in too good of shape for that.”
Well, that is and isn’t true.
First couple of seasons I got into elk hunting I really dove in and got into the fitness aspect of it. I worked out like crazy, focusing on what we often hear “get into the best shape of your life” and “you can’t be in too good of shape”.
So, that’s what I did. The result was I was very strong, had low single-digit body fat percentage and was what most people would consider to be great physical shape.
However, being in “great physical shape” is not the same as being in mountain shape.
Reflecting back, I was in “too good of shape” - but in the wrong areas. There were many things I did well, and others where I missed the mark. For example, I could run a half marathon really well, but could not hike on uneven terrain particularly well. My stabilizing muscles were not where they needed to be for side hilling! Ankles, knees, and hamstrings were absolutely shot after going side hilling through deadfall. As another example: I did lots of sprints those first couple of summers in training, but not nearly enough rucking with a weighted backpack. I could run really fast around the track for 400M, but couldn’t go uphill with a 75 pound backpack on for more than one or two summits in training! Even if I got an elk, it would have been brutal to pack out.
In addition, having a very low body fat percentage was great - for the first day or so…..but really was detrimental afterwards. Going for an 8-10 hour hike in the mountains, one would think having less body fat is beneficial, and it is, but not if you need to make those same types of hikes for sixteen days straight. There is a tipping point where having extra body fat is actually beneficial!
In general, I agree. It is important to be in great shape - great mountain shape - and one can never be in too great of mountain shape!
Good luck this season!