Each of us took home one tote of meat from our moose. That is what Papa Bear had room for in their freezer at that time. We froze it down for the flight home, then processed it at home. We donated the rest and had made arrrangements to do so before our hunt. We weren't just trying to figure it out last minute after our moose were down. One of the pilots had family that was older and no longer able to moose hunt. He was flying hunters during moose season and not able to hunt for them. I helped the people I donated the rest of my moose to load it in their vehicle, they were extremely appreciative. It did not go to waste and I don't feel like this was wrong. I get a beef each year from the family ranch where I work, so I did not need all the meat. What I did take home was excellent and we have enjoyed it very much. It just did not make sense for me to pay processing in Alaska plus shipping for meat that would have mostly been made into burger in my situation. I'd have ended up with around $6/lb the way I figured at the time in burger meat.
If there was a law like you describe I'd follow it and continue hunting, it would not reduce my desire to hunt Alaska. I agree with you 100% about wasting meat being wrong. If people are dumping their meat or allowing it to spoil due to negligence I fully support prosecuting them and/or revoking their rights. We packed every ounce we could whittle off the carcasses out and kept it in good condition. We took pictures of the remainder of the skeleton after removing the meat also in case we got checked, we made every effort to do it right. At camp we elevated it off the ground under a tarp and rotated it regularly until the pilot could fly it out. I was worried about making sure we did this correctly. I bought the video from Larry Bartlett Project Bloodtrail and we watched it, it showed examples of people not used to AK laws leaving to much. It also showed ways to preserve meat longer while in the field. As a first time AK hunter I felt it was helpful.
I don't agree that donating the meat is wrong. If it's going to use by those who need it worse than I do I can't feel bad about that. I'll follow whatever the law states, but I don't feel bad about how we handled it.