I have a buddy who always gives a rutabaga at work white elephant gift parties. It's usually a crowd pleaser. It's not offensive and most people have no idea what to make with it.
Secondhand Sex Toys Mail Prank | Send a "Secondhand Sex Toys" mail prank to a friend. What's Inside? Inside the prank mailer will be a capped, hard cardboard tube with a fake
whatprank.com
Sent this to a buddy, the mailman who delivered and got the required signature thought it was pretty funny
My last white elephant this year had people I know well with a couple are hunters but most aren't. I cut the feet off my last turkey and dried them in a bookend position. I sealed the top cut and the gal that opened them just about threw them across the room when she realized they were real! They got passed around to everyone and it was a good laugh!