I believe wounding rates for vertical bows is off the charts right now. Maybe it always has been. Anyway I assume non tuned bows has alot to do with it. Also Bowtechs at shops don't do near enough education when selling new archery equipment to new hunters. This is why I have a soft spot for RF. He's one of the few that sees this issue and what it may mean for the future.
I think the second part is true, I honestly haven't seen a huge accuracy loss in an untuned bow. I assume the majority of the hunting community (east of the Rockies) are shooting mechanical heads too. An untuned bow will still do the same thing every time, you may have to move your sight around to line up with where your broadheads and they wont group with field tips but they will most of the time group together as long as there are no contact issues anywhere and the shooter is using the same arrow setup for each shot.
I have seen a pile of people shooting bows that do not fit them at all and I believe that contributes more to accuracy loss than an untuned bow. Just yesterday I saw a guy on a hoyt group trying to figure out why he was shooting so far to the left. Looking at his picture his d loop was back by his ear and his string was pressed against his face past his nose, this was with a brand new 2021 hoyt, his local shop told him that because his sight ran out of sideways adjustment they needed to order him a new sight with more adjustment.
I gave him my opinion on shortening his 30" draw and shooting without face pressure and was essentially told he has never been able to shoot with his nose on the string and that he has always shot that draw with no issues. I told him he has always been doing it wrong and if he didn't want real advise he shouldn't have asked.
Anyway, I have seen so many issues with people and poor form, shot execution, or just not knowing they shouldn't shoot 4 different walmart arrows all with different heads from their bow. I've watched guys show up with a stack of arrows at the range and start shooting, they will hit the dirt with their 1st 4 broadheads at 20 yards and when one hits the target they grab it and say "found my #1". A lot of shops are only out to make a buck and sell what they have, even if it doesn't fit properly and almost every shop I've seen will try to sell something they have to a person even if it isn't perfect.
Even with all of the inconsistency in archery, I believe the #1 cause of wound loss is buck fever and poor judgment. I watched my 15-year-old shoot low and clip a small buck right across his brisket this last weekend. He can stack arrows all day long at 60+ yards on the range and his fixed broadheads shoot right with his field tips at 50 yards. He totally air-balled his first shot and didn't even spook the buck, I told him to calm down and make a good shot, I ranged the deer and he still totally whiffed the shot, the worst part is that I was shaking worse than him and I didn't even have a tag
