Cold fingers

Ucsdryder

WKR
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
6,525
Had to take my gloves off yesterday in single digit weather. When I finally got them back on they were numb. Then as they warmed they hurt…I think we’ve all been there, done that. What’s weird is that today they are tender! Just the tips of 3 of them that were cold. I’ve never had that happen before, the next day. If I press them against something it hurts and they’re super sensitive to hot or cold water! Has anybody else done something similar?
 

svivian

WKR
Joined
Mar 16, 2016
Messages
3,170
Location
Colorado
Unfortunately many times especially fly fishing the dead of winter. A few of my fingers are permanently damaged.
 

svivian

WKR
Joined
Mar 16, 2016
Messages
3,170
Location
Colorado
That was my question. Is it a sign of more significant damage?
The pads of a few fingertips have lost the feel of touch completely it took about a week before i noticed the first time it happened.

I keep a set of hot hands in my pack lid and fishing fanny pack now for this reason.
 
OP
Ucsdryder

Ucsdryder

WKR
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
6,525
Gloves are inferior to mitts. Mitts provide a much warmer environment. A set of hot hands is also helpful.
Yeah my first lite mitts were great. But then I took them off trying to get my 12 year old set up on some elk.

I assume it’s temporary. I guess it would have been safer to stay home and play video games…
 
Joined
Dec 7, 2019
Messages
917
I fell in the water duck hunting once. Was 15-20 degrees that morning, don’t remember exactly. Was putting out the decoys and tripped over a submerged stump while fetching one that was floating away. We were in a slough about 700 yds away from my buddy’s cabin with about 15 minutes to shooting light. I tried to grind it out through first light so we could shoot a few before they took me back to change. I made it about 30 minutes into shooting light and started panicking I was so cold. I was mildly uncomfortable for bit then it switched to straight up scary cold. Had them take me back to change and went back out. I still haven’t warmed up from that day. That was 6 years ago…


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
OP
Ucsdryder

Ucsdryder

WKR
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
6,525
I fell in the water duck hunting once. Was 15-20 degrees that morning, don’t remember exactly. Was putting out the decoys tripped over a submerged stump while fetching one that was floating away. We were in a slough about 700 yds away from my buddy’s cabin with about 15 minutes to shooting light. I tried to grind it out through first light so we could shoot a few before they took me back to change. I made it about 30 minutes into shooting light and started panicking I was so cold. I was mildly uncomfortable for bit then it switched to straight up scary cold. Had them take me back to change and went back out. I still haven’t warmed up from that day. That was 6 years ago…


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I remember duck hunting as a youth and absolutely freezing my ass off most days! My feet were always cold!
 

TSAMP

WKR
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
1,640
I purchased a zippo rechargeable hand warmer this year, mostly because I don't wear gloves archery hunting, also because i was tired of tossing the hot hands away. It's gotten a ton of use. It charges in my truck and is always ready to rock. It does have a bit of weight but it's nice. I think for your scenario it'd of been great to get your hands back warm quick.

I think I paid 25 bucks. It lasted me 4 hours on medium.
 
Joined
Dec 7, 2019
Messages
917
I remember duck hunting as a youth and absolutely freezing my ass off most days! My feet were always cold!

Yea feet suck but my hands are the worst. I used to never wear gloves or use hand warners. Didnt bother me a bit. Ever since that day, my hands get cold way easier and after a while they will lock up on me. Getting that cold did something to my body its really strange.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Joined
May 29, 2023
Messages
432
Location
WA
Potentially nerve damage? My feet got pretty beat up a few years ago during a late season hunt. My boots leaked and I was standing in wet snow all day for a few days. Had to thaw my boots out with a warm Nalgene to put them on in the mornings. Cold feet is an understatement. They haven't been the same since and get real cold, real quick. Not sure if it will ever go away.
 

Tod osier

WKR
Joined
Sep 11, 2015
Messages
1,690
Location
Fairfield County, CT Sublette County, WY
Had to take my gloves off yesterday in single digit weather. When I finally got them back on they were numb. Then as they warmed they hurt…I think we’ve all been there, done that. What’s weird is that today they are tender! Just the tips of 3 of them that were cold. I’ve never had that happen before, the next day. If I press them against something it hurts and they’re super sensitive to hot or cold water! Has anybody else done something similar?

Yes, in my experience they will be fine in a day. I have had the same thing several times.

Since everyone is sharing their experience, my hands used to never get painfully cold, even around water in the teens or single duck hunting. They got cold, but warmed up fast. As I age, my fingers get cold like you explain at times. Some days without gloves if it is damp and 40 other days (like this morning) 25 and windy without gloves. Some days the same conditions nothing, but once it starts they stay cold. There is some trigger I don't understand. I'm typing now and a thumb nail feels like it has pressure under it and it wants to pop off. Will be fine.
 

7mm-08

WKR
Joined
Oct 31, 2016
Messages
814
Location
Idaho
My Dad was a part-time school bus driver in the 60's. He was always in a hurry because he worked three jobs at the same time trying his best to make ends meet for our family. One morning during the winter and in -20F weather while on the way to school with a busload of kids, he came upon a lady (a school teacher we knew because everybody knew everybody where I grew up) stuck in a snowbank. Well, he proceeded to pull her out with a chain she had in the trunk of her car WITH NO GLOVES (see first sentence). He later told me that he believed he froze his hands because when he got done, he had to let one of the older teenagers drive the bus to school to drop off the kids because he was unable to move his hands or feel anything - for that entire day. This happened when he was in his 30's and he was the tough (read that "economically challenged") guy who didn't go to the doctor. This incident impacted his ability to do anything with his hands in subfreezing weather from that day forward. I recall that the skin on his hands was so adversely impacted that any little bump caused a huge blood blister to form for the rest of his life.

Moral of the (long and tortured) story - respect the cold with your extremities.

Hope you recover soon.
 
OP
Ucsdryder

Ucsdryder

WKR
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
6,525
My Dad was a part-time school bus driver in the 60's. He was always in a hurry because he worked three jobs at the same time trying his best to make ends meet for our family. One morning during the winter and in -20F weather while on the way to school with a busload of kids, he came upon a lady (a school teacher we knew because everybody knew everybody where I grew up) stuck in a snowbank. Well, he proceeded to pull her out with a chain she had in the trunk of her car WITH NO GLOVES (see first sentence). He later told me that he believed he froze his hands because when he got done, he had to let one of the older teenagers drive the bus to school to drop off the kids because he was unable to move his hands or feel anything - for that entire day. This happened when he was in his 30's and he was the tough (read that "economically challenged") guy who didn't go to the doctor. This incident impacted his ability to do anything with his hands in subfreezing weather from that day forward. I recall that the skin on his hands was so adversely impacted that any little bump caused a huge blood blister to form for the rest of his life.

Moral of the (long and tortured) story - respect the cold with your extremities.

Hope you recover soon.
Pretty positive our dads and granddads were way tougher than us. Fingers are still tender to temperatures but not to pressure.
 
Joined
Jun 21, 2019
Messages
2,547
Location
Missouri
Sounds like mild frostbite or "frostnip" as I've sometimes heard it called. I've had similar experiences a few times with my fingers or toes going numb then feeling sore for a day or two after a night of fish gigging in winter.
 

rclouse79

WKR
Joined
Dec 10, 2019
Messages
1,853
I stayed out too long ice fishing and had similar symptoms. A week or so later the skin peeled off my finger tips.
Now when I leave the truck I open two or three packets of hand warmers and throw them in my pockets. That lets you warm your hands up quick.
 

pewpew69

FNG
Joined
Jun 20, 2023
Messages
13
Sounds like frostnip. Had it happen to my toes skiing with wet socks. I was afraid they'd never go back to normal. They all did within one week except one, but a month or so later it went back to normal (or maybe I stopped noticing the numbness LOL)
 
Joined
Dec 31, 2021
Messages
1,817
Location
Montana
I spent the 70s and 80s trapping beaver without gloves during the winter in Montana. My hands always beamed off heat. Something happened when I turned 60. My trigger finger now gets cold before the rest but now my hands need to be in mitts to survive. I don't think there is a solution short of removing my memory of having warm hands.
 
Joined
Dec 20, 2019
Messages
1,123
I have had numbness and tenderness that lasted a few days. I think you'll be fine. My billing department will contact you by PM.
 
Top