If you have experience with Labs and GSPs, I think you would handle a Brittany well. I wouldn’t say that they have less drive or energy than either of those breeds though – that all depends on pedigree. Field bred Brittanys can be super range-y (150-300 yards) and are often more energetic. Hunt test or show bred Brittanys will typically be closer hunters (25-50 yards) with better “off-switches”, but this all depends on genetics and how you train them. Its much easier to teach a range-y dog to work close than it is to teach a close hunter to range far.
It’s important to evaluate the dam and sire of the litter. Ask the breeder about the dog’s natural tendencies, strengths/weaknesses, and biddability. The breeder should be able to tell you the goals of the breeding program and what traits they have tried to bring out or enhance with the litter. I would look for proper health clearances too. Generally, Brittanys are a healthy breed, but we OFA test hips, elbows, and eyes.
I do agree with others that they are not as heat tolerant as GSPs, and due to their smaller size, can’t cover the same kind of ground that the longer legged GSPs can take on. I am a fan of the smaller size though - easier to travel with and they bring a snappy/zippy enthusiasm to hunts that I haven’t seen in other breeds (hence the nickname “pocket rocket”).
Brittanys are intelligent and versatile and usually pick up on training very quickly (faster than my Labs ever did). Like any breed, some dogs can be super soft and sensitive and others hard- headed. Some good retrievers and some not so much. This also comes down to the intention of the breeder. For example, field trials do not require Brittanys to retrieve (hunt tests do require it), so some breeders may not put as much emphasis on retrieving. Best advice would be to list out the qualities you are looking and then shop around for a breeder that values and specializes in those traits.
I am previously a Lab guy, but we moved to West Texas and have made a full switch to Brittanys due to the upland opportunities out here (we also hunt grouse in the mountains). Our girl is great with our two kids and has a reliable “off switch” when inside. She lets the kids climb all over her and will lay at my feet all day while I work at the office. Unlike Labs, she will not just hang out at your feet while you BBQ outside though. When she walks out the door, she is independent and immediately takes off in hunt mode. Her stamina is on a different level than the Labs. Overall, she is very adaptable, and I’ve been impressed with her willingness to please and how easily she switches gears from family companion to hunting partner.
Not sure where you are located, but we have a breeding planned for February. Check us out at
https://www.facebook.com/wtxbrittanys. You can also PM me if you have any specific questions about Brittanys. Would be happy to tell you more and help you figure out if it’s the right breed for you (and which breeders you should consider). We’ve learned a lot about different breeders while searching for the right stud dog. Could also give you some training lessons learned from going from retrievers to a pointing breed. Good luck!