I have used the same set of black ovis bags for proabaly close to ten animals now (deer and elk). There are a couple small holes in them but I have been happy for the most part. And I have yet to have flys blow through them like I have with other bags
Alaskan game bags are hard to beat for the price! But I found some tag bags in Alaska and they have proven to be the best I have ever used. Clean up like new and are super light weight and tough.
I like my caribou bags I received as a gift. The Black Ovis bags my buddy runs are pretty comparable and a lot cheaper if you watch camofire. Used Alaskan and Argali too... Personally don't think you can go wrong with any of them.
Prob obvious but worth saying... Meat care and speed to getting them in the whatever bag you have is just as important if not more so than the bag brand IMO.
When we lived in Alaska bought all my meat bags at the local thrift store. In their first life they were called pillow cases. Just washed them and sewed a lip on the open end and threaded a piece of parachute cord inside.
Most of the time I paid $.25 to $.50 cents for each
TAG bags for over a decade. Durable, clean up easy and last forever. Great range of sizes to choose from depending on the game species and quartering/boning choice made in the field.
For boned out meat I had my wife make me a few tubular bags, don’t recall exact dimensions but about 8” wide and 24-30” tall out of silnylon. When they’re packed full they are fairly firm and hold their shape so that you can put them in a pack and not get the meat blob that’s so hard to strap down.
Once in camp transfer the meat to a breathable bag- have used pillow cases, cheap game bags, heavy duty cotton game bags, and a set of the lightweight nylon bags, they all work.
After using a Caribou muley set for the last five years and putting hundreds of animals in them, and having some Argali bags for the last nine months and putting a couple of dozen animals in them, I prefer the Caribou bags. Having said that, if all I had were the Argali bags I'd be perfectly happy to use them forever.