Arrow spine far weaker than 3rivers calculator recommends, but arrows fly great.

cck311

FNG
Joined
Apr 23, 2020
Messages
84
Has anybody else ever ran into this? I have recently been shooting the most clean and consistent arrow flight I ever have shot, but according to the 3rivers calculator my arrows should be far too weak. I have am shooting a Samick Sage at 46.5# @ 27.75" draw and my arrows are .600 spine gold tip traditionals with about 210 grains up front (insert and head included) and cut to 28.5 inches. According to the 3rivers calculator I need to be going up a full arrow spine stiffer and then some for these to spine right. These have been flying better than any other arrows I have ever shot. I figured that they must be weak, but that the fletchings were doing their thing and correcting them. I feel like I have all of the inputs entered in accurately and correctly.

A week or so ago I went to an outdoor range with a different set of limbs and a different set of arrows that should have spined perfectly together according to the calculator. That was a majorly frustrating shooting session with the vast majority of the arrows loosed flying poorly with lots of nock right action and lots of far left impacts. Stiff. Today I was shooting a .500 spine bare shaft cut to 29.5" out of the 46.5# limbs and I was having to put on a 250 grain point to get the nock right out of that bare shaft. Far weaker than what the calculator recommends, but the proof is in the pudding I guess. I was curious if I have some kinda wonky form flaw that could be causing this. I feel very strong and aligned at full draw and the arrow flight is very consistent with the "weak" arrows. Anyone have any helpful information or similar experiences?
 
Every once in awhile I will find that all the rules about tuning simply do not work for a specific set up. I used to stress over the "why". Anymore I just go with it and am thankful I found a combo that works.
 
Their spine calculator has been hit or miss for me. I’ve had it be spot on for a bow and way off for others. I just started leaning on the weaker spine side and cutting to tune which has worked very well for me.
 
You are seeing why traditional archers have multiple Home Depot buckets of arrows all with different spines.

If you really want to dive into voodoo mystic tuning, start shooting wood arrows.
 
Back
Top