The ones that fit your feet best should beat any brand recommendations. Everyone’s feet are different and different brands and boots within the same brand can be built on different lasts
Completely agree. Everyone's foot, gait, hips, legs, arches etc. are different - I don't believe there is the "best" boot out there, though I believe everyone has their personal "best" or favorite.
When I first started hunting the Mountain West I asked all my buddies what they wore, read every forum there was - I actually got more confused.
I went to a SCHEELS and tried on every single boot they had in stock - walked around and landed on the Crispi Altitude. Then bucked up and ordered Sheepfeet insoles because I know from playing D1 college sports, taking care of your feet, arches, ankles, hips, knees, et al. is most important thing.
I rocked the Altitudes and then transitioned to the Briksdal MTN's - I like that they're super lightweight, fit my foot and lace-up comfortably, and I can move with them on.
This year, I decided to give the Schnee Beartooth V3's (0g) a try. Met a fella that recommended them over Crispi for durability, honestly did not like them at all. Too big, felt like I couldn't move and hated the height / stiffness of leather. But, the toe box, heel and forefoot felt great. So I put the Sheepfeet insoles in them, and have been giving them hell whilst training for an Elk hunt in MT in a few weeks.
Now, they're my favorite. Do I feel "light and fast," no, not really. I don't even know what that means or if it's remotely possible whilst wearing a heavy pack and traversing elevation through mountainous terrain.
But, I do feel safe, supported and confident on any terrain. And, they'll last 10x longer than any synthetic boot out there. And, they've gotten more comfortable every time I've put them on my feet.
I get 1.5 seasons out of a pair of Altitudes and Briksdals - these Schnees will last (at least) 3x longer than that before needing serious TLC.
I guess what I'm saying is $500 is not the same for everything you spend it on. Just like a boot isn't the same for everyone.