Alaska Sheep Season 2020: New Gear Review

Call Aron, get a Kifaru sent to you, and do a review. Interested to get your take compared to the Barneys.

I would love to try a Kifaru and compare it to the Barney's pack. I've often thought using a different pack on three consecutive backpack hunts would be the ultimate test, I might have to try that next year.
 
I also used the Zeiss Victory Pockets in 8x25 for my last sheep hunt this season. They are phenomenal glass and weigh nothing. Combined with a Kowa 553, they make for a super light and capable optics package.
Peak Refuel and Offgrid Food both made up my meals this season. Try the Offgrid Bison breakfast scramble!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

They are great glass indeed and when combined with a quality spotter, they are all you really need in the way of binoculars on a sheep hunt.
 
This is my opinion based on my experience so take it for what it’s worth. Went from a Barney’s to a Kifaru. There’s actually 4 of us in my group that have in the last few years.

Pick one of the following:

Comfort (Kifaru)
Strength (Barney’s)

Kifaru’s aren’t as durable, not even close. They’re the most durable comfortable pack.

Barney’s aren’t as comfortable, not even close. They’re the most comfortable durable pack.

Haha. Now that is a logical syllogism!

So, if you have to pack 100 lbs one time, which one would you prefer? (Imagine your "standard" miserable pack out).

If you had to pack 100 lbs 10 times for one year, which one would you prefer?
 
Funny you should mention that Nick. A few days after I got done with my last sheep hunt, my feet started to get extremely itchy and irritated. It was impossible not to scratch and it was bad enough to the point it kept me awake at night.

At first I thought I was having some sort of first time eczema outbreak on my feet, now I am thinking I may have had some sort of reaction to the Leukotape as well. I guess I'll make this test scientific and use the hell out of it on Kodiak over the next few weeks and see what happens.

I used leukotape for years wo issues too. But the last 2x I’ve used it, a day after application my feet itch like crazy around the tape. Even a few days after removal.

Sux! I loved that stuff. Lemme know if you find an alternative.
 
I’m in agreement with sldmtn. I have a Barney’s and a stone glacier. The Barney’s is great at hauling a 100 lbs, the stone glacier is way more comfortable with 60 lbs or day loads for me. I do reach for the Barney’s every time if I’m packing a moose quarter or a bear hide, but for backpack hunts I choose the stone glacier every time. Packing 100 plus lbs is normally very little of a hunt and even with a Barney’s pack packing a 100 lbs sucks just a little less.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Great reviews Josh and will take some notes from this.
Out of curiosity, on the pack, i never did look close enough but with the barney pack, have you had any issues with the top of the frame fitting on the shoulders? The reason i went Mystery Ranch (internal frame) and as you call it "yard sale on feet" :ROFLMAO:, is that the few external frames i tried rubbed my shoulders way too much (blame the linebacker width i suppose)and Mystery Ranch rides down the dead center of the back. It does "shift or rock" around the center pad but not horrible enough for me to notice the wear on my lateralis muscles (outside of the thigh). Wondering if this is what you noticed on trials with other packs.

With the Swaro, with the reduced objective lens, light is a small issue in Alaska in early season. The improvement in clarity could be huge as i saw on our hunt last year. Could you tell the difference in judging age on rams as a significant change? Your line of work is way more important and curious if that is where you noticed the difference. I went large and got a Meostar S2 this past year for elk, for future mountain hunts i am throwing the idea around on glass and seeing what i may need in certain situations.

The one i am looking at now is a new sleeping bag and the slick bag was going to be a big contender for me. Weight and synthetic seemed to be your 2 constraints. I am curious if you looked at other things since those 2 limitations still leave huge amounts of options? I am poking at Marmot...expensive i know...but this sparked my interest since i also heard that regular length works well for you as we are close in height...gets old looking at specs and then realize you need a long model that is heavier

Hope all is well and happy hunting!
 
Swarovski STX 65mm Spotting Scope:

Wow, just WOW!!! My old scope is an STM 80mm HD. Before season, I had decided to look for a 65mm In the old style Swarovski scope with the intention to save weight. Well, I was faced with a deal I couldn't refuse and ended up buying a brand new STX with the 65mm objective instead of an STS 65. While I self defeated my purpose of saving weight as the new STX 65 is essentially the same weight as my old STM 80, it is a beautiful piece of glass. When testing it side by side against my old 80, I found it to be crisper and clearer, which is saying a lot because I've always been extremely happy with the old STM. I was very impressed with the STX and unfortunately for my wallet, I can see myself picking up a 95 or 115 objective in the future for my non backpack hunts.

rzxetNY.jpg



Zeiss Victory 10x25 Pocket Binoculars:

While I have had these binoculars for quite a few years this was the first sheep season I have used them since 2015. The past few years I have been using 8x30 Swarovski's coupled with a Marsupial gear bino harness. In my never ending quest to save weight, I decided to go back to the Zeiss's this season and see how I liked it. This allowed me to ditch the bino harness, which I've never been a big fan of anyway, and it saved me a little weight. I carried the 10x25's in either a pant pocket (Fjallraven Keb trousers) or the new Barney's hip belt pouch on my pack. I very much preferred carrying my bino's this way and was glad not to have the cumbersome harness to deal with. It gets old taking the harness on and off every time you want to shed a layer of clothes so I was definitely glad to be without it. The Zeiss's did very well and they will be with me on my sheep hunts in the future. Since I am packing around a spotting scope, big binoculars aren't necessary on sheep hunts and the pocket binoculars are just fine.

Smith and Wesson M&P340, .357 Magnum:

Once again, this hard headed sheep guide is trying to save weight. I don't pack around a rifle when guiding sheep hunters, just a pistol. I have been carrying a lightweight .44 Smith and Wesson in a Diamond D leather chest holster. The past few years, between the sternum strap of my pack, my bino harness, and the Diamond D chest holster with pistol, things were pretty busy on my chest. I decided to start looking for a lightweight .357 and when one popped up on the classifieds last winter, I grabbed it. I was getting tired of the .44 and chest holster system, which when in the Alpine, ended up staying in the tent most of the time anyway while I was out hunting. A lot of good that would do me if I ran into an ornery bear. So I picked up the Smith 340 which saved quite a bit of weight between downsizing pistols and eliminating the chest holster all together. With a little good fortune, the new Smith just barely snugged into the new hip belt pouch of the Barneys pack which was a great way to carry the pistol. The pistol was now quickly accessible and I didn't have a reason to leave it in the tent while I was out hunting for the day.

I picked up some buffalo bore ammo for it, and while quite painful in recoil, I hope to never have to use it for it's intended purpose. I plan on picking up some .38 Special +P rounds in the future and testing those, hopefully making it a little more pleasant to shoot.


Peak Refuel:

Goodbye Mountain House....This season was the first that I tried these meals. They lived up to the hype. While they may be a few dollars more expensive than Mountain House I would say they are well worth the cost. First of all, they just tasted better. And while the portions seemed to be a little smaller than Mountain House, they packed more calories which is another great benefit. Between tasting better and more calories, they are a win win, but the biggest benefit I found was the fact that they use significantly less water than Mountain House. Often in the sheep hills, especially when you get up above brush line, water can be a hard commodity to find. We will often pack up a few days supply of water up the mountain when we know we won't be able to find any up high. With these Peak Refuel meals using less water, it's a no brainer. And did I mention, they taste wayyyyy better than Mountain House. Chicken Pesto Pasta for the win!!


Leukotape:


I wear plastic boots and while I haven't had many foot problems over the years with plastics, there is the occasion that I develop a hot spot or two. On my first hunt my feet/boots got wet while packing a heavy load down hill. The constant pounding of my big toe on the downhill led to a blister. Fortunately, I had a little time between hunts for it to heal up, but the biggest thing I learned from that blister was how well Leukotape works. My hunter had brought some along and let me try it out. It did a great job of alleviating the development of any other hot spots with the wet boots. On the last two hunts, I pre-taped up my feet in the area's I knew I might have issues and the leukotape worked great. I didn't have any problems the last two hunts and will be pre taping my feet on all my backpack hunts in the future.


Vortex 1800 Rangefinder:

When a hunter shows up, we go through their gear and eliminate anything they won't need in an effort to save weight. In order to avoid redundancy we also only bring one range finder. In the past, I usually like to let the hunter bring their own rangefinder, simply for the reason that they are familiar with it and hopefully knows how it works, and in this age of precision shooting (turrets, fancy scopes, etc), I figure it's best to let the hunter use what they are comfortable with.

I am re-thinking that policy. On my first hunt the hunter brought along his vortex rangefinder and I left my Sig behind. Bad idea. Simply put, the vortex sucked. I could barely get it to read, and when it did pick up a reading, anything over 400 yards wasn't happening. Not having a rangefinder that could reliably provide information while we attempted to close the distance on the rams almost cost us. Luckily it didn't and we were able to get close enough that a rangefinder was a moot point, but from here on out I am bringing along the Sig, weight savings be damned.


I think that may be all of the new gear I used this year, at least that I can think of at the moment. If I think of anything else I'll try to add it. There was a lot of new gear for me this year and I am mostly pleased how it all worked. It was a great yet demanding sheep season and as you guys know, having the right gear can make or break a hunt. I know I probably babbled on too much, but hopefully some of this will help out if you are in the market for anything new, and if you all have any questions on my experiences this sheep season, I am always happy too talk all things sheep.


Josh

biOGE2T.jpg
Thanks for the detailed reviews Josh. Based on your recommendation, I went out yesterday and cleaned out a couple 3 Bears of their Peak Refuel meals. Really looking forward to trying these out next month, and the fact that they use so little water to rehydrate, I'm thinking that's going to cut my fuel consumption down considerably.
 
Funny you should mention that Nick. A few days after I got done with my last sheep hunt, my feet started to get extremely itchy and irritated. It was impossible not to scratch and it was bad enough to the point it kept me awake at night.

At first I thought I was having some sort of first time eczema outbreak on my feet, now I am thinking I may have had some sort of reaction to the Leukotape as well. I guess I'll make this test scientific and use the hell out of it on Kodiak over the next few weeks and see what happens.

Itching was the first thing to happen, then a day later she broke out into boils all over her feet where the tape touched... it lasted a few weeks. I would not use the hell out of it on Kodiak unless you want to be sitting out! I can't imagine how bad it would be if we planned to stay a few more days.
 
The Peak Refuels are so much better than other items on the market, less water, better tasting and plenty of calories/protein! They are great...
 
@SLDMTN ’s replies to this thread should be complied and put as a sticky at the top of every forum. It’s refreshing to see an unbiased detailed review from someone who spends a lot of time out there. And honestly this is one of the best gear review threads I’ve read on here. A lot of experience in this thread. Thanks @adventure907 for starting this.
 
Good point Nick, I'll cool my jets on pre taping my feet. Hopefully I won't need the Leukoptape, but we shall see.

And Nugget, you are right, Kyle provides great insight on the Kifaru. You guys are bad for my bank account, now I am getting the bug to see what all this Kifaru praise is all about.
 
My wife is a PT so she always hooked me up with Kinesio tape and it’s worked great for years. We decided to try Leuko tape a few years ago on a hunt and she had the same allergic reaction described above.

Kinesio tape is cotton tape with hypoallergenic acrylic adhesive. Leuko has zinc oxide and latex which are pretty common allergens. Leuko tape gets all the air time, but Kinesio tape is where it’s at. You may get a few less days out of it, but no big deal. It’s heat activated so make sure you activate it by rubbing with hand and creating heat when applying.

I’d recommend bringing both the first time to make sure it’s right for you.
 
Great reviews Josh and will take some notes from this.
Out of curiosity, on the pack, i never did look close enough but with the barney pack, have you had any issues with the top of the frame fitting on the shoulders? The reason i went Mystery Ranch (internal frame) and as you call it "yard sale on feet" :ROFLMAO:, is that the few external frames i tried rubbed my shoulders way too much (blame the linebacker width i suppose)and Mystery Ranch rides down the dead center of the back. It does "shift or rock" around the center pad but not horrible enough for me to notice the wear on my lateralis muscles (outside of the thigh). Wondering if this is what you noticed on trials with other packs.

With the Swaro, with the reduced objective lens, light is a small issue in Alaska in early season. The improvement in clarity could be huge as i saw on our hunt last year. Could you tell the difference in judging age on rams as a significant change? Your line of work is way more important and curious if that is where you noticed the difference. I went large and got a Meostar S2 this past year for elk, for future mountain hunts i am throwing the idea around on glass and seeing what i may need in certain situations.

The one i am looking at now is a new sleeping bag and the slick bag was going to be a big contender for me. Weight and synthetic seemed to be your 2 constraints. I am curious if you looked at other things since those 2 limitations still leave huge amounts of options? I am poking at Marmot...expensive i know...but this sparked my interest since i also heard that regular length works well for you as we are close in height...gets old looking at specs and then realize you need a long model that is heavier

Hope all is well and happy hunting!

I've never had any issues with my shoulders rubbing the frame, but unlike yourself, I am not built like a linebacker, 😂.

The Barney's pack does have quite a bit of adjustment as to how high/low the suspension sits on the frame, so maybe there is something there that would alleviate or avoid the problem you have found with externals. Next time we get to chase some critters together you can give my Barney pack a go. The problem I found with the other packs, every step the weight seemed to shift a little to whichever side foot I was stepping with. Over long distances and or trying to climb heavy in some technical stuff, the weight shift could make things a little dicey.

As far as the spotter goes, it is great! When it comes to aging rams, I imagine the clarity of the new scope does help, but the old STM was great as well and I wouldn't say the difference is significant, but noticeable for sure when comparing both scopes side by side.

I was very happy with the slick bag. I did do some research on other brand synthetic bags, but nothing I found met my requirements like the Kifaru did. Just the fact it came in a wide version was a big seller for me as I can't stand tight mummy cut bags.

Good job on the elk Cragi! I just got home with a caribou I got yesterday, who says 2020 is all bad...
 
Thanks for the detailed reviews Josh. Based on your recommendation, I went out yesterday and cleaned out a couple 3 Bears of their Peak Refuel meals. Really looking forward to trying these out next month, and the fact that they use so little water to rehydrate, I'm thinking that's going to cut my fuel consumption down considerably.
YOu'll love them compared to other freeze drieds.
 
I have a Barneys, that I use strictly for hauling bait in the spring. For backpack hunts, the Kifaru is incredible. I can't imagine wearing a Barney's for days on end, it's just not near as comfortable as a Kifaru.

Surprised to see others have had issues with Leukotape! First time seeing anything about allergic reactions was from my wife, and here there are others who have experienced it as well. I have no issues with it and will continue to use it, but those who have not used it much should certainly be aware.
 
Thanks for the great gear review. Although I am a one time sheep hunter it helps me prepare and remember if the opportunity comes around again.
I will say I am a bit surprised that not everyone knows about Leukotape. Maybe it’s a Marine thing for those of us with baby feet. My guide also developed a blister and when I pulled my 1/4 role (save weight) out of my pack he hadn’t heard of it either.
I don’t mess around anymore and prepare both heels before I ever hit the mountain and it generally stays on the entire hunt.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I have a lot of miles on both a SG and a Barneys. For most recent sheep hunts I use the SG for the lighter weight, but on this years trip I picked up the Barneys again for the volume capacity. I have zero issues with comfort with the Barneys. Fits me great. Hauls great. And is very very stable with a heavy load.

Having to undo the straps on the SG is a thing. But so is having the fish around for that one thing that has gone to the bottom of a Barneys Pinnacle's truck size main bag. I will continue to use both as the need arises.

I've also torn stitching on both at various times and both have patches. Durability has been pretty even up.
 
Josh—thank you for the write up and cannot believe the two things I wanted most for my Barney’s pack exist, and never realized they added the, even between several trips in this summer and fall (picked up some puffy pants there just today). A buddy bought my old pack in 2018 and I grabbed one of the new frames and bags with the updated belt. Using it on the recent moose hunt, I was really, really missing my hip pockets. So nice having snacks easily at hand. Being a bigger guy, I eat and eat often. Certainly more often than I take full breaks. So really like having conveying access to hydration and food without having to stop a d take my pack off. So after missing my snack pockets, the next big thing I was wishing I had as the bag slid down my ass when loaded. was a lumbar pad. Was literally thinking several times on this recent trip, man, I really miss the lumbar pad of my SG. And here it was I coulda had both—as silly as it seems, these two little additions are really such a big deal.

I love my Barney’s bag and Ive tried to dislike my SG after I struggled with getting the belt tension just right the first trip I used it. Talking with SG they helped me sort the issue and it’s non-existent. We picked up a Kifaru pack when in Reno for my brother to use on our early season hunt, and my wife carried it on her late season hunt. I carried it some as well, and really do think the Kifaru suspension is overly comfortable. More robust padding, etc., but swapping back and forth with my brother, I still couldn’t hate my SG. I did get the biggest bag they make as I like having some separate pockets and liked that it is laid out similar to ,overly familiar Barney’s bag. I do not see any use for me personally to the load shelf system on the Kifaru or SG. I want everything in the bag and cinched tight. Maybe for lighter loads and smaller bags, but even then, the whole idea of moving the whole bag load away from my core just doesn’t do it for me.

I couldn’t even complain about my SG or the Kifaru for heavy loads. Brother and I decided enough shuttling once we finished with glaciers and Boulder fields, humping everything for the last several miles in one load. He had about 120# and I was closer to 140# and while it sucked, it wasn’t the packs fault, given the weight they both were as minimally uncomfortable as I could have hoped. I can’t get used to all the webbing loops and hanging pockets and stuff off the kifaru—get that it allows folks to set it up more closely to their individual desires, but not my favorite scenario. Just a personal taste preference as each of the pockets on the pack brother/wife carried performed flawlessly. Still just can’t hate my SG and next sheep or any mountain hunt it’s what I’ll likely carry again. But Moose, big brownies, and wife’s bis0n, it will be the good ol’ Barney’s every time without even a second of thought.

Peak Refuel—if you haven’t had a chance to try the Bison Mashed Potatoes, encourage you to do so. There are a couple of Backpackers Pantry I love, still think Mountain House makes the best tasting lasagne, but for everything else, Peak has it nailed. And best of all of them, hands down, is the Bison Mashed Potatoes. Have order more three times now after running low and this last order was to supply for next year since wasnt sure if the Chad Mendez deal was limited to this year or would change—so had to stock up. And to top it off, since we’ve already noted I’m a big guy that needs to eat—the Bison meal has 1120cals per bag.

Leukotape—never leave home without it. I’m a big guy, and my calves seem to try and rip my big toes off. Probably part of the reason I have what my brother calls freak calves is a I have always pushed off too much with my toes. So usually within a couple weeks of spring hiking, I get “turf-toe” in at least one if not both big toes. Super easy wrap fix with the leukotape that makes a world of difference. So I use it even before or addition to blisters. Word of CAUTiON—remove the stuff carefully, especially with soft feet. Last year in the sierras after long consecutive days of packing, finally got a shower and had been hard at it for almost 20 miles that day and my feet were a little soggy. As showering I reach down and rip the mid-foot anker wrap from the arch area of my foot and, well the tape was stronger than my skin, tearing the sole of my foot right at the mid arch area all the way through the skin layers to meat. Hurt like hell—not just then, but for rest of that trekking trip and couple weeks after I got back to Alaska.

Swaro ATX/STX—usually suck it up and carry my 95mm objective. This year since I was overweighted trying to make sure my brother was able to ease in a bit on his first sheep hunt, so brought the 65mm objective to save the weight, which isnt insignificant. Have used Swaro almost exclusively (Basically for everything but rangefinder, and this year trying out Lieca range binos), and in all that time had never experienced an issue or failure. Had to happen sooner or later—so might have well expected it would be on a sheep hunt where we spend so much time on the glass. Anyway, with all the rain, I guess the objective had lost pressure at some point and by the time we were little over half way through the hunt, it had fogged up from all the rain. So need to send it back for Swaro magic, which one thing thats so nice about Swaro is I’m not sweating it. I’ll get it sent off sometime here soon, and no stress as a I know theyll take care of it. So, minor hiccup and horrible time, but guess all gear subject to failure at some point. And Josh, the 95mm is simply badass. I hate carrying it, did for both 2018 and 2019 sheep hunts and glad as did. And again for wife’s late season hunt. But man is it bulky and heavy. Going to try and ignore that the 115mm even exists, but bet it’s cool.

Simple things for me this year that I was super impressed with was going to an MSR pocket stove and ti mug over the jet boil. I’ve always been a huge jet boil fanboy, so can’t believe I’m admitting that, but it was a significant improveKent. Next was my Crispot Brikstal stiffs, love these boots. So comfortable and light compared to my previous boots. And then the little kestrel ti knife. Still. Fought my havalon expecting my brother could use it, but I ended up doing all the cutting and every animal this year, most of the work was done with that little dude. blades are all the same, it’s just I like the thin profile with square edges of the handle, give a secure feeling in hand.
 
So now I have to go ask Kevin to mail me pockets and lumbar pad. One thing I really would love to see Barney’s do it add a bag option constructed from x-pack. Really like that stuff.
 
Back
Top