Ok so did some more testing. I wanted to test if seating the bullet was causing my issue. I seated the bullet back into the case .005" at a time and it still wouldn't fit.
The next test was smoking my brass. I took a lighter and covered it in silt. I attempted to chamber and it appears to have contact right past the shoulder. See in picture 1.
View attachment 936627
Picture 2 is from my borescope and you can see black silt left in chamber.
View attachment 936628
Picture 3 is from a piece of brass that does fit and you can see right past the shoulder you have black silt from contact in chamber from the leftover. That seems really tight to me. Do I potentially have a crazy tight chamber? My 1x fired case at a datum measurement of 1.896 and my 2nd fired case at a datum measurement of the same 1.896. Reamer prints show minimum would be 1.900. If it's hitting there then this wouldn't be a shoulder bump issue correct?
View attachment 936633