22lr vs 22wmr for coons

22lr is not impressive on coon, but it is quiet. I shoot them with 22mag pistol, which is about like 22lr rifle except loud. Not impressive either, but I hunt over dogs. That's another story.

I think you have to consider where you will place the bullet. Need more velocity for vitals shot than head shot. And if you have a pet dog, do not involve it. A coon is the meanest thing in the woods.
 
Thanks for all the replys. I applaud the guys that only ever head shoot a coon as Im not that good. I occasionally hit them back and still would like the most ethical round within reason. Coons are def tough sob if you dont hit them just right. How would you compare the noise between a 17 22lr and a 22 mag. Thanks
 
Ive killed a boat load of coon with CCI .22 quiets and Aguila Super Colibri. Super Colibri are only 20grains and only going about 500fps. Hit em right in the forehead at 25yards or closer, they drop everytime. That being said, if you cant head shoot em they will suck up a few rounds of either 22lr or 22mag. Id use 22lr for sure over WMR, way quieter with subsonincs.
 
I can’t even remember how many raccoons we shot with a 22lr. Back in the late 80’s, and early 90’s when they were actually still worth shooting and skinning we would run them at least 5 nights a week during season. Now if I do happen to catch a raccoon in one of my canine trap sets I just release them unless they are injured. It’s just not worth the couple bucks you might get from a good pelt.

They are a lot more effective if you use quality hollow point Ammo like CCI mini mags or something similar.
 
I have a continual battle with raccoons because I raise chickens. I have shot a bunch with both. The .22 mag is the way to go. Clean one shot kills. They are tough little critters.
 
As someone with 40+ years and 10,000++ coon experience, all you need is a .22LR.
You have a sitting target in a tree. If you think you're under gunned, go home and leave it to the pro's.
 
I’ve killed literally thousands of coons with 22LR, a vast majority of them with a simple Ruger Mark II. The photo below is less than one month’s worth of hunting, thawing in the sun before heading to the furbuyer.

87F09610-13C1-48D7-94D2-6E6AF7A2D8AA.jpeg
827D7D4E-CFB6-4D3D-BDE5-330605D99AA1.jpeg
 
Really appreciate the guys with a realistic perspective on the matter. We aren't all pros and get a perfect headshot. Millions of animals are shot with guns that are way over powered. I'm guessing a 30 06 might be excessive for a whitetail but if it has an advantage then I'm all for it. Like I said I'm not a gun guy so thanks for the input that goes beyond telling everyone how awesome you are. Really do appreciate the rest of your input. I'm not a pro so maybe I should just go home and give up hunting as mentioned. Really. .....
 
I applaud the guys that only ever head shoot a coon as Im not that good.


We aren't all pros and get a perfect headshot.

@bignocks - you’ve rang this particular bell a couple of times, so I’d feel remiss if I didn’t address it. We’re not talking about a “22LR for headshots, Howitzer for vitals shots,” type of scenario here. Headshots are the fastest, easiest kill, with the least influence on pelt value, but coons don’t always present a headshot. While a majority of the thousands I have killed have been headshots, I’d venture a quarter to a third have been vitals shots. They fight longer, but they die just as dead when using a 22LR on the heart and lungs as they do when putting it on their head.

I’d actually argue vitals shots are EASIER for 22LR. It’s not so uncommon to find mushroomed bullets on the surface of the skull - even with 22 mag HP’s. The coons typically die all the same, but from the impact, not destruction of the brain. I’ve skinned a few which we’d thought we’d missed multiple times, and then found two or three, or four mushrooms smashed on the outside of the skull. Impacts on vitals will penetrate and take out the heart and lungs, impacts on brain box may not penetrate. They just die faster when you hit them in the noggin. Solid RN’s and Mini-Mags don’t act like that - they penetrate.

So it’s really not a matter of getting that perfect headshot to concede to a lack of power, it’s just a matter of realizing you don’t need extra power, and don’t benefit from it.
 
@bignocks - you’ve rang this particular bell a couple of times, so I’d feel remiss if I didn’t address it. We’re not talking about a “22LR for headshots, Howitzer for vitals shots,” type of scenario here. Headshots are the fastest, easiest kill, with the least influence on pelt value, but coons don’t always present a headshot. While a majority of the thousands I have killed have been headshots, I’d venture a quarter to a third have been vitals shots. They fight longer, but they die just as dead when using a 22LR on the heart and lungs as they do when putting it on their head.

I’d actually argue vitals shots are EASIER for 22LR. It’s not so uncommon to find mushroomed bullets on the surface of the skull - even with 22 mag HP’s. The coons typically die all the same, but from the impact, not destruction of the brain. I’ve skinned a few which we’d thought we’d missed multiple times, and then found two or three, or four mushrooms smashed on the outside of the skull. Impacts on vitals will penetrate and take out the heart and lungs, impacts on brain box may not penetrate. They just die faster when you hit them in the noggin. Solid RN’s and Mini-Mags don’t act like that - they penetrate.

So it’s really not a matter of getting that perfect headshot to concede to a lack of power, it’s just a matter of realizing you don’t need extra power, and don’t benefit from it.
Thank you. That's some awesome info that I can use in my decision making process. Appreciate the time you took to write that. Good luck on your hunts and hopefully I'll have a pile like you soon. I've been an archery guy forever and and like to fine tune my setup for lethality and accuracy so im trying to hit the ground running on the rifle side as archery took forever to learn and educate myself.
 
Back
Top